Inmates in need of abortion services at the Cuyahoga County Jail in Ohio will now receive transportation to clinics that can perform the procedure. The county will also provide sex education programs and information on contraception, abortion, and adoption to inmates as part of a legal settlement reached with a former prisoner, Yuriko Kawaguchi. In 1998, Judge Patricia Cleary sentenced Kawaguchi to six months in jail on forgery charges. Kawaguchi contends that Cleary only sentenced her to jail after learning that she was pregnant and seeking an abortion. The Ohio Supreme Court later suspended Cleary – a vocal anti-choice supporter – from practicing law because of her biased ruling in the Kawaguchi case. With the help of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), Kawaguchi, who was forced to carry her pregnancy to term, then sued the jail. As part of the settlement, Kawaguchi will receive only $1,000.
Migration Category: NCWP Old Site
State Department Releases Trafficking Report
In a press conference held earlier today, Secretary of State Colin Powell unveiled the Annual Trafficking in Persons (TIP) Report, mandated by the Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of 2000. This year, the report investigated government anti-trafficking efforts in 89 countries, excluding those with insufficient information or fewer than 100 trafficking cases. As with the 2001 TIP report, countries were categorized into three tiers based on compliance with the Act and level of government commitment in combating the criminal activity, particularly in the areas of prosecution, victim protection, and public education.
The report identified 19 “Tier 3” countries, all failing to comply with the Act and demonstrating little effort to meet the standards: Afghanistan, Armenia, Bahrain, Belarus Bosnia, Cambodia, Greece, Indonesia, Iran, Kyrgyzstan, Lebanon, Myanmar, Qatar, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Tajikistan, Turkey, and the United Arab Emirates. While the number of “Tier 3” countries declined from 23 reported last year, Powell urged continued international cooperation. “The annual Trafficking in Persons Report shines a much-needed light on this global problem. We use the information we collect to bolster the will of the international community to combat this unconscionable crime. We welcome and encourage the vital sharing of information by other countries, nongovernmental organizations, and individuals,” said Powell. “The US seeks to work with all nations to document this egregious form of exploitation and to cooperate with them to end it once and for all.”
Fifty-two countries were classified as “Tier 2″Ñ not meeting full compliance with the Act’s minimum standards, but making significant efforts to do so. Eighteen countries were deemed “Tier 1,” or fully compliant. South Korea, recognized for its “extraordinary strides” in the past year, advanced from “Tier 3” into “Tier 1.”
The Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act 2000 states that by 2003, sanctions could be imposed on “Tier 3” countries.
Landmark Domestic Violence Case Set to Begin
Mara Teresa Macias v. Sonoma County Sheriff Mark Ihde will be heard in a San Francisco courthouse beginning on June 17th. Mara Teresa Macias was shot to death by her estranged husband, Avelino Macias, on April 15, 1996. Her mother was also shot, but survived. Prior to her death, Teresa had called the Sonoma County Sheriff’s Department more than 20 times to report her estranged husband’s violence, sexual assaults, stalking, and threats to kill both Teresa and her mother. Despite California law and county policy requiring arrest on domestic violence and domestic violence restraining order violations, the sheriff’s department never arrested or cited Macias, and only filed two police reports. By failing to enforce the law, Macias was free to track Teresa down and murder her. The lawsuit seeks to establish a woman’s constitutional right under the Equal Protection Clause to hold police legally accountable for their response to violence against women.
Report Documents Police Abuse Against Women Motorists
A new report by the Police Professionalism Initiative at the University of Nebraska at Omaha documents disturbing nationwide occurrences of female drivers being stopped by male police officers and subjected to sexual harassment and assault. The report examined a decade of over 400 media accounts describing incidents across the United States. Only 100 of the incidents resulted in official sanctions against the officer. In one instance, a Long Island police officer was suspended after admitting he had forced a woman to undress in public in exchange for not writing a traffic ticket. Experts expect that this study is only a small representation of the extent of these situations, since many women are reluctant to report police misconduct because of fear of reprisal or humiliation. The study’s name, “Driving While Female,” parallels the pattern of racial profiling of motorists, often referred to by the term “Driving While Black.” The report utilizes research by the National Center for Women & Policing to call on police departments to adopt a zero tolerance policy on harassment of female drivers, and to hire more female officers to reduce the risk of misconduct.
Miami Police Department’s Practices to be Examined by Department of Justice
After a series of cases of excessive force, unjustified shootings, and evidence planting, the U.S. Department of Justice has decided to send a team of investigators to review the Miami Police Department. The city and the Chief have said that they welcome the investigation, which comes shortly after this year’s highly publicized case where 13 current and former Miami police officers were indicted on charges of unjustified shooting, altering crime scenes, planting guns and lying to investigators. The Department of Justice will examine the Miami PD for between three to six months, and determine what course of action should be taken to reform the department.
Honduran Women Trafficked in Texas
Forty Honduran women and girls, lured by the promise of jobs as maids and waitresses, trekked for days from Choluteca, Honduras to Fort Worth, Texas only to be tricked and forced into a Texas couple’s sex trafficking ring. In testimony delivered last Friday, Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) Special Agent George Ramirez described the sex trafficking operation run by Antonio Molina, 32, and Guadalupe Molina, 27, as an extensive network beginning with relatives recruiting Choluteca women aged 19 to 23 years old and girls aged 14 to 16 years old, followed by the transport and subsequent housing of victims under constant surveillance in Fort Worth homes and apartments maintained by the Molinas. According to Ramirez, one woman was repeatedly raped during the journey and immediately following arrival, all of the victims were forced to work at bars, promoting beer sales and providing prostitution services.
The May 16 raid of the “Molina organization” resulted in 88 arrests. US Magistrate Judge Charles Bleil charged the couple with conspiracy to harbor undocumented immigrants, and the couple was jailed without bail. As one local Honduran following the story commented, “It’s horrible. People are looking for the American dream to build a better life, but nobody knows the risk along the way.”
According to officials at the Second World Congress Against Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children held in December 2001, sex trafficking is the third most lucrative criminal activity in the world after smuggling arms and narcotics. According to the 2000 Annual Trafficking in Persons Report issued by the US State Department, between 45,000 and 50,000 people “mostly women and children” are trafficked to the United States and forced to work in sweatshop like conditions or in the sex industries as prostitutes. The United Nations, however, estimates that between 244,000 and 325,000 women and children are victims of commercial sexual exploitation in the United States.
City Officials Must Pay $10 Million to Women Wrongfully Strip Searched
The city of Boston and the Suffolk County Sheriff’s Department in Massachusetts settled a class-action lawsuit this week, agreeing to pay $10 million to over 5,000 women who were wrongfully strip searched at a local jail over a period of four years. The women, many of whom were arrested for petty crimes including failure to return an overdue video game and selling goods without a permit, were also subjected to searches of their vaginas and rectums. The women were all arrested after normal business hours and were – for a variety of reasons – not released on bail and thus transported to the county jail where the searches took place.
Originally, the city and the sheriff’s department argued that the women had no bases for their suit. US District Court Judge Nancy Gertner, however, found that the strip searches violated the constitutional rights of the women involved. Compensation will now be given to the women based on the types of crimes committed. Women who were arrested for misdemeanors will receive the largest payouts versus women arrested for sex or drug crimes.
Women Banned From Army Ground Reconnaissance Units
Eight female soldiers training to perform ground sweeps in the mountains of Afghanistan were removed from their Reconnaissance, Surveillance and Target Acquisition squadrons, an Army spokeswoman announced yesterday. The female soldiers were reassigned after the implementation of a Pentagon mandate forbidding women from participating in ground reconnaissance units, a reversal of a Clinton administration policy that made these units open to women. The mandate came despite an earlier Army announcement that it had no plans to change the units’ mixed-sex status, according to the Washington Times.
The ban also comes in the wake of another troubling Bush Administration change that may limit the role of women in the military. In March, the Pentagon fired all members of the Defense Advisory Committee on Women in the Services (DACOWITS) and rewrote the charter for the 51-year-old committee severely restricting its role and forbidding independent site visits to military installations. While a new committee is currently being put together, no commitment has been made to ensure that women are adequately represented on the panel.
The destruction of the panel is even more disturbing as a federal district court struck down the Army’s promotional affirmative action policy this year. Despite 1997 figures that show women make up a mere 14 percent of Army personnel, the policy was deemed to unfairly favor women and minorities, according to the judge. A DACOWITS report in 1997 found that the practice of male commanders denying women leadership positions and assigning them to desk duty was “widespread.” At some bases, women were “openly demeaned and their roles in the military ridiculed.”
Washington Post Urges Increased Effort to Combat Sex Slavery
In an editorial appearing in today’s Washington Post, the newspaper called on the US to withhold aid from countries that are not working vigorously enough to curb sex trafficking and sex slavery. The Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of 2000 establishes global standards for the elimination of sex trafficking and allows the US government to apply pressure to countries found in violation of those standards. Among the biggest offenders, according to the Washington Post, are India, Thailand, and Cambodia. The State Department notes that more than 2.3 million women and girls are forced prostitutes in India. In Thailand, child sex slaves number close to 1 million, and in Cambodia, and estimated 20,000 child sex slaves work out of brothels. The Washington Post reports, however, that these countries were not included on a list developed by the State Department in 2001 of nations found to be too “complacent” about prosecuting and convicting sex traffickers. “There is an internal debate about which countries will be fingered; country specialists within the department, concerned about causing offense that might damage other US interests, tend to want leniency,” explained the Post. “But naming and shaming offending countries is a good way to stimulate the prosecutorial crackdowns that could actually curb sex slavery.” The State Department is now preparing to publish its 2002 list.
Sex trafficking is the third most lucrative criminal activity in the world after smuggling arms and narcotics according to officials present at the Second World Congress Against Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children held in December 2001. The United States, itself, is not immune to sex trafficking. According to the 2000 Annual Trafficking in Persons Report issued by the State Department, between 45,000 and 50,000 people – mostly women and children – are trafficked to the United States and forced to work in sweatshop like conditions or in the sex industries as prostitutes. The United Nations, however, estimates that between 244,000 and 325,000 women and children are victims of commercial sexual exploitation in the United States.
Detroit’s Chief Calls for Tougher Discipline of Officers
Police Chief Jerry Oliver of the Detroit Police Department called for improved discipline and scrutiny of his department’s police officers yesterday, stating that there are “criminals” currently working for the department. Oliver criticized the lack of accountability held by many officers, and the assumption that prosecutors and Internal Affairs will grant officers ‘professional courtesy’ and dismiss their charges. There are currently 300 backlogged cases in the Internal Affairs division, with many of the cases being serious crimes. Oliver cited one case of an officer who he fired just last week, after it came to his attention that the officer had been found guilty of sexually assaulting a female prisoner four years ago. While there has been support for Oliver’s stance from the civil rights community, the police union and others have condemned the Chief’s remarks as inflammatory and extreme. John Goldpaugh, a lawyer for the police officer’s union, said “It appears to me that the chief’s position is that if you are charged with a misdemeanor – regardless of its nature – that you can’t be a police officer. Well one of those misdemeanors is domestic assaults, and because I have an altercation with my wife or significant otherÉ does that mean the guy should be fired automatically?” The attorney’s comments make clear a prevalent attitude within a sector of the law enforcement community that downplays the seriousness of domestic assault. This is especially disturbing when one considers that a police officer who commits domestic violence in his own home will also be responding to citizen’s domestic violence calls, which account for over half of all violent crime calls to police departments. Studies on the rate of domestic violence in police families show that they are 2-4 times more likely to experience domestic violence than the average American family. Police officers who commit domestic violence are rarely prosecuted, and often protected by fellow officers, while their families fail to receive adequate justice from law enforcement.
Violence Against Women Leads to Major Health Problems Globally
Preliminary data collected by the World Health Organization(WHO) found that women worldwide suffer from severe health problems resulting from pervasive violence against women. WHO found that as many as 60 percent of women in rural areas of Peru, Thailand, and Brazil are victims of violence, and in other parts of the world, two in three women experienced violence. The WHO study also documents that this widespread violence also leads to major health problems for women including miscarriage, depression, alcoholism, and infections resulting from sexual assault. Domestic violence, which includes marital rape, was also found to contribute to the spread of HIV/AIDS among women. The findings will be used to encourage governments to create social policies to combat violence against women.
Priest Pleads Guilty to Date-Rape Drug Charges
A Roman Catholic priest from Illinois pled guilty this week to charges that he conspired to make and distribute gamma hydroxybutyric acid (GHB), also known as the “date-rape” drug. Rev. Jeffrey Windy allegedly had a chemical solvent used to make the drug delivered to St. Patrick’s Church in Sheffield, Illinois where he worked and then made the drug at a friend’s home. GHB can be used as a hallucinogen or as a means to incapacitate people for the purpose of committing sexual assault. Windy now faces up to 20 years in prison and $1 million in fines. He is to be sentenced on August 22. Windy’s guilty plea came on the same day that an appeals panel rejected an effort to reduce the sentence of Boston pedophile priest, John Geoghan. Geoghan received a 9-10 year sentence for molesting a 10-year old boy in 1991. Lawyers were attempting to reduce the sentence to 2 years with 8 years of probation. Despite this failed attempt, Geoffrey Packard, Geoghan’s attorney, indicated that Geoghan intends to appeal his conviction.
Judiciary Committee Approves Anti-Women’s Rights Nominee
In a 12-7 vote, the Senate Judiciary Committee approved the nomination of Judge D. Brooks Smith to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals. The nomination will now head to the Senate floor for a full vote. Numerous women’s rights and civil rights groups, including the Feminist Majority, opposed the nomination of Smith because of his anti-women’s rights record. These groups now vow to fight the nomination on the floor.
Judge Smith is an ardent opponent of the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), which originally gave a victim of gender violence the ability to sue her attacker in federal court. In a speech to the right-wing Federalist Society, Smith stated that a federal court should not be the forum for such lawsuits and federal laws should not try to protect women from violence. While a Federal District Court Judge, Smith also retained membership in an exclusive all-male club, the Spruce Creek Rod and Gun Club until 1999. Membership in an all-male club shows contempt for women’s equality that is incompatible with the responsibilities of a federal judge; such membership rightly causes litigants to question a judge’s ability to treat women fairly, especially women involved in sexual harassment or sexual discrimination cases.
Three Democrats joined Committee Republicans to vote in favor of Judge D. Brooks Smith: Sens. Joseph Biden (D-DE), Herb Kohl (D-WI), and John Edwards (D-NC).
Philadelphia Gets Rid of Lie-Detector Tests
A directive was issued this week by the Philadelphia Police Department that removes the passage of a lie detector test as a condition of employment. The Department made the decision after reviewing recent studies that show polygraph tests to be unreliable, often measuring a person’s nervousness as opposed to honesty. “I think that there are a lot of applicants who would have made outstanding police officers that were rejected because they couldn’t pass the polygraph,” said Philadelphia Police Commissioner Sylvester Johnson. Johnson argued that in the face of a recent wave of Philadelphia corruption scandals that clearly the polygraph is not weeding out all the potentially corrupt candidates, and that the department can better uncover character flaws by doing more extensive background checks. He also added that drug screening, which is one of the prime purposes of the polygraph, is more accurately done through new hair sampling techniques. There has been some dissent among anonymous Philadelphia officials, who argue that officers need as much screening as possible, and that the polygraph is good at catching bad candidates. Many cities in the U.S. still use polygraph tests, including Baltimore, Los Angeles, Denver, Phoenix and Dallas. However, New York City, and many other cities, have never used them, and have no plans to instate them.
Pittsburgh Police May be Released from Federal Oversight
The Pittsburgh Police Bureau’s 1997 consent decree mandating federal oversight over departmental procedure may be lifted as soon as this summer. The city is currently negotiating a release from the decree, arguing that problems of excessive force, false arrests, and internal affairs corruption have been corrected. Pittsburgh agreed to the consent decree in April of 1997 in order to avoid a federal take-over of the Police Bureau. In the years prior to the consent decree, the city had been plagued by high-turnover, having had 5 police chiefs in 10 years, and had no institutionalized training or standard reporting policies, resulting in procedures that varied from station to station. As part of its consent decree, the city has developed the now nationally recognized Performance Assessment and Review System, which allows supervisors to easily access an officer’s complete employment history, and to be informed any time something abnormal occurs. Another condition was the creation of a Citizen Police Review Board.
Some civil rights groups have expressed opposition to a lifting of the consent decree. Their fears that reforms will be eroded if federal oversight is ended are well founded. The Pittsburgh Police Bureau came under another consent decree in 1975, which mandated increased hiring of women and African-Americans. At the time the court order was imposed, women comprised only 1% of the department. By 1990, the department had one of the highest representations of women police officers in the country at 27.2%. However, when the court order was lifted in 1991, the number of women hired dropped dramatically, from an average of over 40% to a current 8.5% of all new hires. As of 2001, the percentage of women serving as police officers had dropped to 22%. The expiration of consent decrees is thought to be a major contributor to the current decline in the percentage of women in policing nationwide.
Veteran Woman Officer Named as Chief of the Metro Transit Police
Polly Hanson, a 21-year veteran of Metro Transit Police in Washington, D.C., broke a glass ceiling for women today with the announcement that she will become her department’s first woman chief on July 1st. Hansen, 46, will lead over 350 sworn officers, and will oversee the safety of more than a million bus and rail customers, nearly 10,000 Metro employees, and a patrol area covering 1500 square miles. She is only the second woman in the U.S. to head the police department of a major transit agency. She joins Chief Mary Rabadeau, who is Chief of the New Jersey Transit Police, and was a speaker on preparedness for biological and chemical attacks at the recent National Center for Women & Policing 7th Annual Leadership Conference. The National Center congratulates Chief Hansen on her appointment, and welcomes her to the growing community of women chiefs!