Trump Rescinds Obama Administration Protections for Transgender Students

On Wednesday President Trump rescinded Obama era protections that allowed transgender students access to whichever restroom corresponded with their gender identity as a condition of the education equity guaranteed under Title IX.

In a joint letter from the Department of Justice and Department of Education, the Trump administration claimed that the Obama administration had not sought proper legal analysis or provided appropriate explanation for why these protections were guaranteed under Title IX. The letter added, “The Departments believe that, in this context, there must be due regard for the primary role of the States and local school districts in establishing educational policy.”

“What could possibly motivate a blind and cruel attack on young children like this?” said President of the Human Rights Campaign Chad Griffin. Griffin continued, “This isn’t a ‘states rights’ issue, it’s a civil rights issue. Children deserve protection from bullying no matter where they live. Period.”

The New York Times argues that Attorney General Jeff Sessions wanted to act quickly to roll back this protection before two pending court cases moved forward, with the result of potentially upholding the protections and forcing the government into further litigation. Many are saying that this quick directive is highlighting the influence that Sessions has in the new Cabinet.

In August, a federal judge in Texas issued a preliminary, nationwide injunction blocking the Obama administration from enforcing the extended Title IX protections for transgender students, after 13 states challenged Obama’s guidelines insisting the administration had gone too far. This injunction is still in place, meaning that the federal government has not been enforcing the Obama administration’s extended Title IX protection.

The ACLU is confident that the case of Gavin Grimm, a 17 year old transgender student who was barred from using the boys’ restroom at his Virginia high school, will move forward successfully in the Supreme Court, where oral arguments are scheduled to begin at the end of March.

A statement from the ACLU’s James Esseks reads, “While it’s disappointing to see the Trump administration revoke the guidance, the administration cannot chance what Title IX means. When it decided to hear Gavin Grimm’s case, the Supreme Court said it would decide which interpretation of Title IX is correct, without taking any administration’s guidance into consideration. We’re confident that the law is on Gavin’s side and he will prevail just as he did in the Fourth Circuit.”

According to the Williams Institute at the UCLA School of Law, approximately 150,000 teenagers 13 to 17 identify as transgender. The Boy Scouts of America recently dropped a century-old ban on transgender boys, and will now admit members based on the gender listed by the child or parent on the application, rather than the sex listed on the child’s birth certificate.

Read the 2016 Title IX Obama Administration Dear Colleague Letter and the Department of Education’s Examples of Policies and Emerging Practices for Supporting Transgender Students.

Media Resources: Washington Post 2/22/17; Human Rights Campaign 2/22/17; New York Times 2/22/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 8/22/16, 10/31/16, 2/7/17; NPR 2/22/17; ACLU 2/22/17

Virginia Governor Vetoes Bill to Block Abortion Providers from Title X Funding

On Tuesday, Virginia Governor Terry McAuliffe vetoed a bill that would have eliminated some of funding received by Planned Parenthood and other organizations that perform abortion services. The bill, HB 2264, was introduced by Delegate Benjamin L. Cline and was approved 60-33 in the House of Delegates before being passed last week by the Senate.

HB 2264 would have specifically cut off Title X funding to organizations that perform abortion despite the fact that Title X funding does not directly pay for those services due to the longstanding Hyde Amendment, instead funding STI/STD testing, cancer screenings and birth control access for women who do not qualify for Medicaid but cannot afford health insurance.

Title X of the Public Health Services Act is the only federal domestic program that is exclusively concerned with providing funds for family planning and reproductive health services. Title X funding is awarded through competitive grants to whichever healthcare providers prove they are best qualified for meeting the needs of the communities they serve.

McAuliffe vetoed a similar Title X funding bill last year. The Delegate who introduced the bill expressed a hope that the General Assembly would be able to override the Governor’s veto.

Last week, the U.S. House of Representatives voted 230-188 to rescind an Obama administration rule, finalized in December, that was meant to block states from being able to cut off funding to organizations that offer abortion care. It is expected to successfully pass through the Senate. Since 2011, 13 states have passed legislation restricting clinics that offer abortion services from accessing Title X funds.

In 2015, over 4 million people received healthcare from over 3,900 facilities funded under Title X. According to the Center for American Progress, women’s health centers who receive money through Title X prevent 1 million unintended pregnancies each year that would have otherwise resulted in 501,000 more unplanned births and 345,000 more abortions.

Republicans in Congress have attempted to eliminate Title X funding completely in every Congress for the last seven years while claiming that women seeking reproductive health services can go to other clinics funded by Title X if abortion providers are forced to shut down.

In addition to attempting to eliminate and allowing states to block women’s health centers from accessing Title X funding, the House is also working on a measure that would block Planned Parenthood from receiving any Medicaid reimbursement for servicing low-income patients. Planned Parenthood provides healthcare to 2.5 million people each year and estimates that 80 percent of those services are to prevent unintended pregnancy.

Almost two weeks ago, anti-abortion groups held protests outside of Planned Parenthood clinics across the country to advocate for defunding the healthcare organization. They were met by thousands of abortion rights advocates in 45 states who oftentimes outnumbered the anti-abortion demonstrators.

Media Resources: The Loudoun Times-Mirror 2/7/17; Virginia’s Legislative Information System 2017 Session; The Feminist Majority Foundation 12/15/16, 2/16/17; Richmond Times Dispatch 1/21/17; Vox 2/16/17

Expanded Global Gag Rule Already Threatening Lives

Since Donald Trump reinstated and expanded the Global Gag Rule his first week in the White House, public health non-governmental organizations (NGO), international governments, and even USAID have been scrambling to pick up the pieces and figure out exactly how far reaching this executive order goes.

The original Global Gag Rule bans any overseas NGO that receives US family planning and reproductive health funding from providing or distributing information about abortions, even using funding from non-US government sources, forcing NGOs to choose between accepting vital US funding or offering information, referrals or services for abortion. Trump expanded it to include global health programs across all agencies, meaning that Global Gag now not only applies to family planning organizations, but also NGOs that work to combat public health epidemics such as HIV/AIDS, malaria, Zika, and much more.

The Global Gag Rule is already devastating initiatives aiming to bring healthcare and empowerment to women. The Huffington Post recently chronicled the reality of the Marie Stopes International (MSI) Eastleigh clinic in Nairobi, Kenya, a country where 75 percent of abortions are done unsafely, making it a leading cause of maternal death.

MSI knows that when women and girls need to terminate a pregnancy, they will do so no matter what, and MSI is refusing to deny them safe abortions and contribute to the tens of thousands of deaths caused by botched abortions globally each year. This means they are about to lose a $3 million deal with USAID meant to expand their contraceptive access program to 75,000 more women in rural Kenya. Currently there are 225 million women of reproductive age around the globe who want the ability to avoid pregnancy but are not accessing modern contraception.

The expanded Global Gag Rule effects approximately $9 billion in aid a year, and major philanthropists like Bill and Melinda Gates have said that there is no amount of increased funding that foundations like theirs could give to bridge the gap left by the expanded Global Gag. Bill Gates made clear, “The US is the No 1 donor in the work that we do. Government aid can’t be replaced by philanthropy. When government leaves an area like that, it can’t be offset, there isn’t a real alternative. This expansion of this policy, depending on how it’s implemented, could create a void that even a foundation like ours can’t fill.”

International governments are scrambling to soften the devastating impact of lost US funding, but even they will not be able to scrape together near sufficient funds. So far $32 million has been raised among the Belgian, Dutch and Danish governments, and Norway has pledged an additional $10 million to abortion funds. Canada, Luxemborg, Sweden, Finland, Estonia and Cape Verde have pledged their support but have not yet said how much they will contribute.

Shortly after Trump’s executive order, Congresswoman Nita M. Lowey (D-NY) and Senator Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH) introduced legislation in the House and Senate respectively to permanently repeal the Global Gag Rule. The Global Health, Empowerment and Rights (HER) Act would allow organizations to continue to receive US funding while paying for anything abortion related out of their own pockets.

The Feminist Majority Foundation, in partnership with over a dozen other organizations, is holding a protest on March 8 in Washington DC to raise awareness about the Global Gag Rule and advocate for its repeal.

Media Resources: Feminist Majority Foundation 1/24/16; The Hill 1/30/17; Huffington Post 2/9/17, 2/21/17; The Guardian 2/14/17; Devex 2/21/17; New York Magazine 1/24/17.

Government Moves Forward with Mass Deportation Agenda

President Trump’s promise to ramp up the deportation of undocumented immigrants hit a new stride on Monday when Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary John Kelly issued memos for how to carry out Trump’s two sweeping executive orders giving the federal government almost unrestrained ability to arrest, detain and deport immigrants. The memos include directives to expand the group of undocumented immigrants prioritized for deportation, expedite removals, and recruit or deputize thousands of additional law enforcement agents to arrest suspected undocumented immigrants.

The plans are a far cry from former-President Obama’s executive orders regarding immigration. The executive order, directed toward Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), indicates that all undocumented immigrants that have been charged with a crime, or “have committed acts that constitute a chargeable criminal offense,” even if not convicted, must be prioritized for deportation. As being in the United States without documentation is in itself considered a crime, this order makes all 11 million undocumented immigrants in the United States a “priority” for deportation.  President Trump has already directed the DHS to compile and release a weekly list of crimes “committed by aliens and any jurisdiction that ignored or otherwise failed to honor any detainers with respect to such aliens.”

In order to carry out the mass deportation of this expanded prioritized group, the President is resurrecting a failed Obama-era program that automatically checked the immigration status of anyone checked into local jails. In addition, the order allows for ICE’s Enforcement and Removal Operations office to triple in size. ICE will also be able to deputize countless local law enforcement agents to act with the authority of federal officials in arresting and detaining undocumented immigrants as part of ICE’s immigration “task force.” A number of states and sanctuary cities have refused to allow their officers to take part in this initiative.

According to Vox, “Using local police to enforce immigration law makes it easy to depict everyone being deported as a criminal—otherwise, why would local police have come across them to begin with? But in practice, the 287(g) and Secure Communities program aren’t just baskets to catch immigrants, but vacuums that actively suck them up.”

The President’s signed executive order lays out a strategy of deporting undocumented immigrants prior to their trials as a method for managing the back pile of court cases that are likely to continue to grow exponentially. Anyone who has been in the country for less than two years can be deported immediately.

While this is an option given to ICE officials in Kelly’s memo, he also calls for all undocumented immigrants to be detained no matter what, even if they are in the US seeking asylum, a detention capacity that the government does not currently have.  In addition, according to Vox, immigrants held in detention facilities have a much more difficult time receiving a fair trial.

Children would not be exempt from this harsh scrutiny and treatment under the new executive orders. The memo outlines methods for deporting children who are crossing the border alone, either fleeing violence or reuniting with family already in the States, suggesting DHS change the definition of who is considered an unaccompanied child and deport the relatives that the child has come to the US to join.

Joanne Linn, senior legislative counsel from American Civil Liberties Union, commented on the memos, saying, “Due process, human decency, and common sense are treated as inconvenient obstacles on the path to mass deportation. The Trump administration is intent on inflicting cruelty on millions of immigrant families across the country.”

Trump has put immigration at the forefront of his first 100 days as President, introducing an executive order earlier this month attempting to institute what has now become commonly known as the “Muslim ban,” in which he attempted to ban the entry of immigrants and visa holders from seven Muslim-majority countries into the Unites States. This ban has been placed on hold since the 9th Circuit of Appeals ruled against Trump’s highly controversial executive order. Trump plans to release a revised order that will not include the initial ban on Syrian refugees, but will still target the same seven countries that were included in the first order.

Resources: Vox 2/21/17; Washington Post 2/18; The Independent 2/21; Feminist Majority Foundation 2/1; ABC News 2/20; New York Times 2/21/17

 

Senate Confirms Scott Pruitt as Administrator of the EPA

Friday the Senate voted to confirm Scott Pruitt as the Administrator of the Environment Protection Agency. Pruitt was confirmed with a vote of 52-46.

Pruitt, a self-proclaimed “leading advocate against the EPA’s activist agenda,” is an avid climate change denier, fossil fuel supporter and collaborator with oil and gas companies.

Prior to his confirmation many EPA employees, including lawyers, policy advocates and scientists, launched a nationwide effort asking the Senate to oppose his confirmation. Last week, employees held an “anti-Pruitt” rally, during which they called for an EPA leader who would actually uphold the mission and values of the agency.

Democratic Senators unsuccessfully called for a delay of his confirmation vote after an Oklahoma County district judge yesterday ordered Pruitt to turn over public official documents to the Center for Media and Democracy, a watchdog group currently bringing a lawsuit against Pruitt for violating the Open Records Act. Pruitt has failed to comply with their 2015 request to release correspondence between himself and Koch Industries, as well as other mining and drilling corporations.

Pruitt claims to be a firm believer in expanding state’s rights to make their own decisions on environmental regulations and has made it a staple of his career to do what he can to eliminate federal efforts to save the environment. During his time as Attorney General of Oklahoma, Pruitt led efforts to reverse climate change protections and energy renewal initiatives made under the Obama Administration. He has repeatedly sued the EPA and attempted to block regulations on mercury and air toxin standards for power plants, as well as abolish the Regional Haze Rule, which protects the air surrounding national parks.

The appointment of Pruitt to run the EPA is part of a greater movement of the Trump Administration to do away with many of the environmental protections and reforms enacted during the Obama Administration. President Trump himself vowed to “get rid of” the EPA.

Evidence on global climate change as a result of human activity is overwhelming and has garnered wide-spread scientific consensus among leading scientific societies. 2016 saw some of the hottest months on record with average temperatures that had not been seen in 136 years. According to NASA, sea level rise, global temperature rise, the warming of our oceans, shrinking ice sheets, glacial retreat, declining Arctic sea ice, ocean acidification and declining snow cover are just a few among the many outcomes and signs indicting rapid environmental deterioration as a consequence of climate change.

Climate change has a profound effect on the female population around the globe. In developing nations, women account for over 50% of the agricultural workforce and the affects of climate change would have a detrimental impact on their livelihoods.

Media resources: FMF 10/8/16; CNBC 2/17/17; New York Times 2/16/17; Climate Central 9/12/16;NPR 2/17/17; UN Women Watch

Puzder Withdraws and a New Labor Secretary is Nominated

Today, President Trump announced Alexander Acosta, a former federal judge and current law school dean, as his nominee to serve as secretary of the Department of Labor following Andrew Puzder’s Wednesday afternoon withdrawal of his nomination.

Acosta, who once clerked for Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, served as assistant attorney general for the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division during the George W. Bush administration. Acosta was born in Cuba and, if confirmed, would be the first Hispanic member of Trump’s Cabinet.

“Following the failed nomination of Andrew Puzder, it is incumbent upon the Senate to conduct a thorough review of Alexander Acosta’s record,” said Wade Henderson, president and CEO of The Leadership Conference, in a statement released Thursday. He continued, “The American people deserve someone who will look out for their interests, and not just the interests of corporations.”

Andrew Puzder, whose Senate confirmation hearing to lead the Department of Labor was scheduled to begin Thursday morning, withdrew his nomination after a broad group of more than half a dozen Republican Senators expressed concerns over supporting his nomination.

Democratic Senators began calling on him to withdraw his nomination earlier this month, arguing that Puzder’s public statements as well as his record as a businessman reflect that he is “an enemy, not a champion of workers.”

Andrew Puzder is the CEO of CKE Restaurants, which owns fast-food chains Hardee’s and Carl’s Jr. During Puzder’s tenure, CKE restaurants and franchises were investigated by the Department of Labor numerous times, and they found violations of wage and hour laws, such as failure to pay overtime or the minimum wage, in 60 percent of those investigations. Puzder also has a contentious history of domestic abuse and created a brand culture that was based on the objectification and sexualization of women.

In a January forum organized by Senate Democrats, workers employed by Carl’s Jr. and Hardee’s, both fast-food chains owned by CKE Restaurants, the company of which Puzder is CEO, testified about the wage theft and refusal to pay overtime that runs rampant throughout the franchises.

“I honestly can’t think of anyone less qualified to enforce laws that are supposed to protect employees,” said Laura McDonald, a general manager who worked for CKE for over 20 years. “He never protected the employees he was in charge of at CKE, so I do not think he would be the person to protect American workers’ rights.”

“Puzder should never have even been nominated to lead the Labor Department, and Senate Republicans clearly recognized this, too,” said Senator Schumer. “The fact that someone so anti-labor was even nominated shows how far President Trump is from where he campaigned.”

Media Resources: Slate 2/16/17; San Diego Tribune 2/16/17; New York Times 2/15/17;  The Leadership Conference 2/16/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 1/12/17, 2/9/17.

House Moves to Rescind Protection for Women’s Health Centers

This week the House Rules Committee sent legislation to the House floor that would rescind an Obama administration rule, finalized in December, that is meant to block states from cutting off federal funding to organizations that offer abortion care, ensuring that women’s health centers continue to receive Title X funds for other health services including STI/STD testing, cancer screenings and birth control access.

This measure, which is different than Congress’s plan to block Planned Parenthood from receiving Medicaid reimbursements, would give states the option to take away funding from women’s health centers and is set to be voted on today. Neither Medicaid nor Title X funds can be used to pay for abortion services due to the longstanding Hyde Amendment.

Title X of the Public Health Services Act is the only federal domestic program that is exclusively concerned with providing funds for family planning and reproductive health services. Title X funding is awarded through competitive grants to whichever healthcare providers prove they are best qualified for meeting the needs of the communities they serve.

In 2015, over 4 million people received healthcare from over 3,900 facilities funded under Title X, a third of which were Planned Parenthood clinics. Many of those who utilize Title X funding make too much to qualify for Medicaid, but too little to afford birth control and other reproductive health services. Over half of those who accessed healthcare under Title X were women of color.

According to the Center for American Progress, women’s health centers that receive money from Title X prevent 1 million unintended pregnancies each year that would have resulted in 501,000 unplanned births and 345,000 abortions.

Since 2011, 13 states have restricted access to Title X grants for women’s health centers that offer abortion services. In Texas, 82 women’s health clinics have closed since lawmakers cut family planning funds by 66 percent in 2011. Between 2010 and 2012, the maternal mortality rate in Texas doubled, a spike the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology called hard to explain, “in the absence of war, natural disaster, or severe economic upheaval.”

In addition to allowing states to block women’s health centers from accessing Title X funding, the House is also working on a measure that would block Planned Parenthood from receiving any Medicaid reimbursements for servicing low-income patients, an amount that currently stands around $500 million per year. Planned Parenthood provides reproductive healthcare to 2.5 million people each year, and estimates that 80 percent of those services are to prevent unintended pregnancy. In over 20 percent of the counties they serve, they are the only women’s health center.

“This is a priority for Republicans,” said House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi. “So I just would like to speak individually to women across America: this is about respect for you, for your judgement about your personal decisions in terms of your reproductive needs, the size and timing of your family or the rest, not to be determined by the insurance company or by the Republican ideological right-wing caucus in the House of Representatives.”

Last weekend, anti-abortion groups held protests outside of Planned Parenthood clinics across the country to advocate for defunding the healthcare organization. They were met by thousands of abortion rights advocates in 45 states, who oftentimes outnumbered the anti-abortion demonstrators.

Media Resources: Feminist Majority Foundation 12/15/16, 2/15/17, 8/23/16, 1/6/117; USA Today 2/14/17; Center for American Progress 2/9/17; Vox 2/16/17

Planned Parenthood Supporters Appear in Thousands to Counter-Protest Anti-Abortion Groups

Abortion rights signs, like “Women’s rights are human rights,” and pink “pussy hats,” which have become symbols of the Women’s March Global movement, juxtaposed anti-abortion protesters’ signs this past weekend, as abortion rights advocates counter-protested anti-abortion groups at Planned Parenthood locations across the country.

Nearly 150 collections of Planned Parenthood supporters turned out, ranging in size from dozens to thousands at parks, government buildings, and clinics in 45 states, and oftentimes even outnumbered the amount of anti-abortion protesters. In St. Paul, Minnesota, police reported that about 500 anti-abortion protesters were met by nearly 5,500 abortion rights protesters.

While many anti-abortion groups see President Trump, Vice President Pence, newly confirmed Secretary of Health and Human Services Tom Price, and Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch as the answer to “hearing {their} trumpet call” to eventually overturning Roe v. Wade and defunding Planned Parenthood, supporters of the organization see the Trump administration as a serious threat to access to birth control, reproductive health services, and cancer screenings, which constitute the majority of services provided by Planned Parenthood.

Though Planned Parenthood is pleased with the amount of support they are receiving as the organization is under siege, the interim vice president of Planned Parenthood Mary Alice Carter released a statement on Saturday asking that supporters not carry out counter-protests outside of the organization’s health centers, due to concerns that “these rallies can often be intimidating, and can inadvertently prevent patients from getting the care they need.” Carter suggests, “Instead we encourage supporters to attend events away from health centers, become a patient escort, or rally outside their elected officials offices.”

Typically it is not an outpouring of supporters present outside of women’s health clinics, but rather groups engaged in anti-abortion activity. According to the Feminist Majority Foundation’s (FMF) 2016 National Clinic Violence Survey released last week, the overwhelming majority of clinics (91.1 percent) experienced some type of anti-abortion activity—such as protesting—in the first half of 2016, with 63.2 percent of providers experiencing activity at least once a week, and a quarter of clinics experiencing it every day.

FMF produced a spotlight video to accompany the release of the survey called “Walking the Gauntlet” to demonstrate the extreme tactics employed by the anti-abortion industry to intimidate patients, staff and doctors in front of the clinics. These may appear to be ordinary protesters, but many are in fact trained operatives engaged in a systematic campaign to shut down access to women’s health clinics.

Planned Parenthood has been under increasing scrutiny since the 2015 release of the fraudulent videos by the so-called Center for Medical Progress (CMP), an anti-abortion group that falsely accused Planned Parenthood of illegally selling fetal tissue. The now thoroughly debunked videos ignited 13 state and 3 Congressional investigations, each of which found zero evidence of wrongdoing. Planned Parenthood is proceeding with a federal racketeering lawsuit against CMP.

Against the backdrop of the misleading videos, the 2016 National Clinic Violence Survey found that the number of clinics experiencing the most severe threats and violence has skyrocketed since 2014, from 19.7 percent to 34.2 percent. Severe violence and threats include death threats, stalking, and blocking access to clinics. Half of clinics in the United States (49.5) experienced at least one incident of severe violence and/or severe harassment, such as break-ins or vandalism.

Become a Feminist First Responder to support clinics under attack. There are a number of activities you can choose from, including becoming a clinic escort, volunteering as a legal observer, and providing emergency security assistance to clinics under siege.

Read the full report of the survey results here.

Sources: Reuters 2/11; FMF 2/9; Common Dreams 2/11; Planned Parenthood 2/11

Advocates Urge Education Secretary Betsy DeVos to Protect and Enforce Title IX

People across the country today are participating in a national day of action, calling the Department of Education to ask that new Education Secretary Betsy DeVos uphold the civil rights of all students by protecting and enforcing Title IX, the federal law that prohibits sex discrimination in federally-funded education programs.

Despite strong public protest against her nomination, the Senate confirmed DeVos to serve as the Secretary of Education last week, but only after Vice President Mike Pence cast a tie-breaking vote in her favor. Only two Republicans voted against her confirmation: Senators Susan Collins (R-ME) and Lisa Murkowski (R-AK).

Advocates for Title IX, including the Feminist Majority Foundation, strongly opposed DeVos’s confirmation, citing her consistent failure to support Title IX and its commitment to providing all students with a safe environment, free from discrimination and violence. Instead, her family foundation has supported Grove City College, an institution notorious for refusing to comply with Title IX, and DeVos herself has given thousands of dollars to the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE), a group that has actively opposed the Department of Education’s guidance on sexual assault and has sought to make it more difficult for survivors to prove sexual misconduct in school grievance hearings.

When asked in her confirmation hearing whether she intended to uphold the Department’s guidance concerning sexual assault on college campuses, DeVos said an immediate decision on the matter would be “premature.” She went on to voice her support for the Safe Campus Act, a bill that would require sexual assault survivors to file a report with the police if they wanted their school to investigate a sex crime. The bill, supported by FIRE, was so extreme that groups representing fraternities and sororities had to backtrack on their early support of the bill because of student outcry.

Students, parents, educators, and activists today are calling the Department of Education, saying they want Secretary DeVos to know that they want the Department to keep in place Title IX guidance on preventing and addressing sexual harassment and assault as well as guidance on protecting transgender students from discrimination. Activists are also saying they want the Department’s Office for Civil Rights (OCR) to continue its strong enforcement of Title IX and to keep publishing the list of schools under investigation for Title IX violations.

The Department of Education can be reached at 202-401-3000 or 1-800-USA-LEARN.

Media Resources: Feminist Newswire 2/7/17; Washington Post 1/18/17; The Atlantic 11/19/15

Threats and Violence Against Abortion Providers Has Skyrocketed, According to FMF Survey

The Feminist Majority Foundation (FMF) has released the results of the 2016 National Clinic Violence Survey, an analysis of the anti-abortion violence, intimidation and harassment that occurred at women’s health clinics across the country in the first six months of 2016.

The survey found that the number of clinics that experienced the most severe types of threats and violence has skyrocketed since 2014, from 19.7 percent to 34.2 percent. Severe violence and threats include death threats, stalking, and blocking access to clinics. Half of the clinics in the United States (49.5 percent) experienced at least one incident of severe violence and/or severe harassment, such as break-ins or vandalism.

For example, in October of 2016 a Missouri man pleaded guilty to a federal charge of violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrance Act, which makes it a crime to intentionally damage a reproductive health clinic because of the services offered there, after he attempted to burn down his town’s Planned Parenthood clinic twice. In the same month, a Maryland man pleaded guilty to vandalizing a women’s healthcare facility, spray painting “Baby Killer,” “Kill Baby Here” and other comments on a Baltimore clinic in what he admitted was an attempt to intimidate women from accessing reproductive healthcare.

In addition to severe violence, threats and harassment, the survey found that the overwhelming majority of clinics (91.1 percent) experienced some type of anti-abortion activity—such as protesting—in the first half of 2016, with 63.2 percent of providers experiencing activity at least once a week, and a quarter of clinics experiencing it every day. FMF produced a spotlight video to accompany the release of the survey called “Walking the Gauntlet” to demonstrate the extreme tactics employed by the anti-abortion industry to intimidate patients, clinic staff and doctors in front of the clinic. These may appear to be ordinary protesters, but many are in fact trained operatives engaged in a systematic campaign to shut down access to women’s health clinics.

At times, anti-abortion groups will organize large events, bringing people from across the country, to target, intimidate and harass specific women’s health centers. Just this summer, Operation Save America (OSA), an anti-abortion extremist group based in Waco, Texas, led a week-long campaign against South Wind Women’s Center and Planned Parenthood in Wichita, Kansas to mark the 25th anniversary of Operation Rescue’s 1991 Summer of Mercy, a six-week protest during which 2,700 extremists were arrested for blockading three abortion clinics in Wichita, including the clinic of Dr. George Tiller who was later murdered by an anti-abortion extremist in 2009.

During this summer’s protest, Rusty Thomas, the leader of OSA, issued an open letter to police calling on them to, “insist their states immediately outlaw abortion, grant the police the authority to shut down any death camp in their jurisdiction, and arrest those who participate in the barbaric act of abortion.” Instead, the Wichita Police Department worked closely with local clinics—and protesters—to ensure patient and staff access and safety, and invested significant resources to maintaining the peace during the weeklong campaign by the outside group.

According to FMF’s 2016 Clinic Violence Survey, women’s health centers that rated their experience with law enforcement as “poor” or “fair” were significantly more likely to experience high levels of severe violence and harassment (47 percent) than those who rated local law enforcement “good” or “excellent” (16 percent).

In addition to targeting clinics, many doctors and clinic staff are targeted by anti-abortion extremist groups directly. 46.4 percent of clinics in 2016 reported the targeting of staff and physicians, most frequently by pamphlets like the KILLERS AMONG US leaflets featuring doctors’ photographs and home addresses, as well as the distribution of WANTED style posters.

According to the survey report, “Beginning in the early 1990’s an undeniable pattern emerged between the use of WANTED posters and the murder of the doctors named on the posters. Drs. Gunn, Britton, Slepian and Tiller were all murdered by anti-abortion extremists; all had been featured prior to their murder on WANTED posters with their home and clinic addresses and in some cases, their photographs.”

“We’ve been doing this survey since 1993 and seen time and time again that this rhetoric quickly escalates to threats. And when threats go up, violence occurs,” said Eleanor Smeal, president of the Feminist Majority Foundation. “You cannot consistently call women and doctors murderers and then escape responsibility when others are emboldened to commit violence.”

Threats, harassment and acts of violence against abortion providers, which were already high, saw the increase outlined in the survey against the backdrop of the 2015 release of fraudulent videos by the so-called Center for Medical Progress (CMP), an anti-abortion group that falsely accused Planned Parenthood of illegally selling fetal tissue. The now thoroughly debunked videos ignited 13 state and 3 Congressional investigations, each of which found zero evidence of wrongdoing. Planned Parenthood is proceeding with a federal racketeering lawsuit against CMP.

Despite these facts, a House Select Investigative Panel investigating abortion providers came to a close only a month ago, after over a year of waging a “McCarthyesque witch hunt,” abusing Congressional authority and subpoena power to intimidate, threaten and endanger the lives of abortion providers and biomedical research professionals. Both the video and the subsequent House Select Panel investigation have been accused of increasing the threats and violence towards abortion providers, including the 2015 shooting at a Colorado Springs Planned Parenthood that killed three people and injured nine.

Companies and individuals both targeted and not targeted by the videos found themselves the focus of invasive and dangerous Congressional subpoenas demanding names of employees involved with handling fetal tissue, putting their lives at risk. Some of those forced to testify before the Panel were compared to Nazi war criminals, and some now require 24-hour personal security. Multiple clinics and tissue procurement agencies stopped facilitating fetal tissue donations because of the threats inspired by CMP and the Panel investigation. In April, a Washington man pleaded guilty in federal court to threatening the lives of biomedical research employees targeted by the Panel and encouraging others to kill them.

Clinics and their staffs across the country are facing severe and consistent threats, and they need your help. Become a Feminist First Responder to support clinics under attack. There are a number of activities you can choose from, including becoming a clinic escort, volunteering as a legal observer, and providing emergency security assistance to clinics under siege.

Read the full 2016 National Clinic Violence Survey report here.

Media Resources: Feminist Majority Foundation 2/9/17, 10/19/16, 8/5/16, 2/9/17, 1/5/17.

 

Afghanistan Sees Increase in Conflict Related Civilian Casualties

The United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan’s (UNAMA) 2016 report shows an increase in conflict related civilian casualties to the highest recorded number since 2009. According to the UNAMA annual report on the Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict, civilian casualties in Afghanistan increased by 3.7% last year, comprising 11,418 conflict-related civilian casualties with 3,498 killed and 7,920 injured. Since 2009 the conflict in Afghanistan has claimed the lives of 24,841 civilians and injured 45,347.

The report has found that the 2016 conflict severely impacted Afghan children, with 923 deaths and 2,589 injuries, a 24 percent increase from 2015 and the highest child casualty rate UNAMA has ever recorded. The number of women killed or injured in conflict, 341 and 877 respectively, decreased by 2 percent from the previous year.

According to the report, attacks by anti-government forces, most significantly the Taliban, accounted for 61 percent of the civilian casualties, with casualties caused by ISIS increasing by ten times in 2016. Airstrikes carried out by the Afghan government and other international forces led to the deaths of 250 civilians and the injury of 340, almost twice the number of casualties as in 2015 and the highest recorded number since 2009.

Just one day after the UNAMA’s report came out, a suicide bomb targeting Supreme Court employees took place in a parking lot near the court in the Afghan capital of Kabul, killing 21 people and wounding 41 others.

The United Nations and Afghan government both reacted to the violence, condemning the attacks on civilians and calling on anti-government forces, as well as the Afghan and international forces, to take urgent steps to end civilian casualties and reduce the use of explosive weapons.

“Unless all parties to the conflict make serious efforts to review and address the consequences of their operations, the levels of civilian casualties, displacement and other types of human suffering are likely to remain at appallingly high levels,” said Tadamichi Yamamoto, the UN Security General’s Special Representative for Afghanistan.

Zeid Ra’ad Al Hussein, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights decried the violence, stating, “Children have been killed, blinded, crippled – or inadvertently caused the death of their friends – while playing with unexploded ordinance that is negligently left behind by parties to the conflict. Women continue to be brutally punished in parallel so-called ‘justice’ processes while religious minorities are targeted as they pray in their mosques.”

The Afghan government released a statement saying that it is taking all necessary steps to protect the lives of civilians and minimize damage to property during military operations. “The Government of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan puts the safety of lives and properties of the civilians among its fundamental agenda and main objectives. Government will consider legal action in case damage is caused by the security and defense forces to civilians,” reads the press release. The press release concludes that, “the president once again clarifies that the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan instead considers the Taliban and other terrorist groups accountable to ensure the safety of people’s lives and properties.”

Despite the persistent terrorist attacks, Afghanistan is a nation that continues to make considerable progress. The most encouraging advancements are the falling infant, child and maternal mortality rates, and the increase in access to trained midwives. Additionally, women are being encouraged to participate and are actively taking roles in STEM work, and some 80 percent of Afghan women now have regular or occasional access to mobile phones. There are now distance learning literacy programs sponsored by USAID and mobile health apps for use during pregnancy and other health conditions.

Media Resources: TOLO 2/8/17, 2/6/17, 2/7/17, 2/6/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 12/20/16

 

Arizona May Soon Require Abortion Providers to Check for “Evidence of Life”

An anti-abortion bill has been introduced in the state of Arizona that would require medical providers to search for “evidence of life” while performing an abortion. If passed, doctors will be forced to look for signs of life during the procedure, such as “evidence of breathing, a heartbeat, umbilical cord pulsations, and definite movement of voluntary muscles.”

The supposed purpose of this requirement would be to ensure the abortion does not result in a live birth.  According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the chances of pregnancy termination resulting in a termination of a live birth are extremely unlikely. However, if this bill were to be implemented, doctors and staff risk penalty of perjury if they fail to conduct the “examination.”

The bill was introduced on January 31st and already has the backing of twenty state representatives and sixteen state senators as well as the Center for the Arizona Policy.

Abortion providers and advocates are concerned that this bill will further the undue burdens placed on providers, preventing safe and legal access to abortion services. In an interview conducted by Rewire News, California OB-GYN Dr. David Klein expressed his concern, arguing that “Increasing the capability of clinics to include intensive care…would likely require an incredible burden on clinics and would likely force their closure—an issue addressed in the recent Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt case.”

This is not the first bill expected to create unnecessary restrictions and barriers on abortion services and providers in Arizona. Arizona is among the 25 states with laws and/or policies perpetuating the targeted regulation of abortion providers. These restrictions include but are not limited to a required state-directed counseling discouraging abortion, a 24-hour waiting period before undergoing an abortion, parental consent of a minor’s procedure, a required ultrasound and the requirement that abortion facilities are equipped like surgical centers.

Whether or not these burdens will continue to expand is to be determined. The “Evidence of Life” bill is being reviewed by the Senate Health and Human Services Committee and Senate Rules Committee and was read a second time by the Senate on February 1st.

Media Resources: Fifty-third Legislature of the State of Arizona Senate 2017, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2003-2014, Center for the Arizona Policy 1/26/17, Rewire News 2/6/17, Guttmacher Institute 2/17, Guttmacher Institute 1/17

 

Senate Leaders, Workers, and Advocates Call for Withdrawal of Puzder Nomination for Labor Secretary

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) and Senator Patty Murray (D-WA), Ranking Member of the Senate Health, Education, Labor & Pensions (HELP) Committee, joined with fast food workers and advocates to call for the withdrawal of Andrew Puzder as nominee for Secretary of Labor.

At a press conference this morning, Senator Schumer said that Puzder’s public statements as well as his record as a businessman reflect that he is “an enemy, not a champion of workers.” Schumer likened having Puzder as Labor Secretary to “having a fox guard the henhouse, and a pretty sharp-toothed fox at that.”

Andrew Puzder is the CEO of CKE restaurants, which owns fast-food chains Hardee’s and Carl’s Jr. During Puzder’s tenure, CKE restaurants and franchises were investigated by the Department of Labor (DOL) numerous times, and the DOL found violations of wage and hour laws, such as failure to pay overtime or the minimum wage, in 60 percent of those investigations.

On Monday, Puzder admitted that he had employed a housekeeper for years and never paid any legally-required taxes on her wages, in violation of state and federal law. Puzder only paid back taxes when his nomination was imminent. In response, over 100 advocacy organizations, led by the National Employment Law Project and Jobs with Justice and including the Feminist Majority Foundation, issued a statement this morning saying “enough is enough” and calling for the Trump Administration to withdraw Puzder’s nomination.

In their statement, the organizations noted that “Mr. Puzder is an experienced attorney and CEO of a major fast-food empire, so he cannot plausibly claim ignorance of his legal obligations as an employer.” They continue, “We already have ample cause to doubt Mr. Puzder’s fitness for the job as Secretary of Labor, and this latest news confirms our view that he should not be confirmed. If he cannot be trusted to follow even one of the most basic laws of employment in his own home, there is no way we can expect him to enforce the crucial laws the Department of Labor oversees on behalf of working people.”

Senator Patty Murray reinforced that call this morning, stating “There simply should not be one set of rules for the Trump cabinet and another for everyone else.” She called Puzder “uniquely unqualified” to serve as Secretary of Labor, noting that “his decision to pick and choose what laws he himself follows is disqualifying.”

The core mission of the Department of Labor is “to foster, promote, and develop the welfare of the wage earners, job seekers, and retirees of the United States; improve working conditions; advance opportunities for profitable employment; and assure work-related benefits and rights.” Yet, Puzder has shown outright hostility toward workers, in particular vulnerable, low-wage workers, such as those employed in the fast-food industry. Puzder has opposed the raising the minimum wage, opposed paid sick leave, and has actively sexualized and objectified women’s bodies in order to sell hamburgers. He also has questioned the very worth of workers. In a 2016 interview with Business Insider, Puzder said he would be willing to replace workers with machines, commenting, that machines “are always polite, they always upsell, they never take a vacation, they never show up late, there’s never a slip-and-fall, or an age, sex, or race discrimination case.”

After numerous delays for failure to submit his required paperwork, Puzder is scheduled to have a hearing on his nomination in the Senate HELP Committee next Thursday. The Feminist Majority Foundation has strongly opposed his nomination.

Media Resources: C-Span, 2/9/17; Los Angeles Times, 2/7/17; Feminist Newswire 1/12/17; Business Insider, 3/16/16; Department of Labor; U.S. Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor & Pensions; Jobs with Justice and Economic Policy Institute

Jeff Sessions Confirmed as Attorney General

On Wednesday evening, Alabama Senator Jeff Sessions was confirmed as US Attorney General with a final vote of 52-47 after nearly thirty hours of debate, during which Democratic senators voiced their strong opposition to Sessions’ confirmation.

The debate took on an even more heated tone after Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) had Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) barred from speaking on the floor following her reading of a 1986 letter written by the late Coretta Scott King, in which King opposes Sessions’ nomination for a federal judgeship, accusing him of using “the awesome power of his office to chill the free exercise of the vote by black citizens.” McConnell accused Warren of ascribing “to another senator or to other senators any conduct or motive unworthy or unbecoming of a senator,” a violation of Rule XIX.

Democratic Senators quickly pointed out the hypocrisy of such an accusation, given that the rule is frequently never enforced, and that the case is unique as Sessions, though a sitting senator, was the topic of the debate due to his nomination. Since Senator Warren’s removal, other Democratic senators have sought to finish what Warren started and have successfully read the letter on the Senate floor.

McConnell stated, “She was warned. She was given an explanation. Nevertheless, she persisted.”

Concern over Sessions’ appointment has stemmed from his prosecutorial and senatorial records, and whether or not he would be willing and able to enforce laws that he actively opposes. Sessions has not been steadfast in condemning violence against women, voting against the re-authorization of the Violence Against Women Act because of its expansions to immigrant women, Native American women and college students. Sessions has called Roe V. Wade a “colossally erroneous” decision and has repeatedly and unsuccessfully tried to undermine the right to abortion through legislation, putting him well out of the mainstream, as evidenced by the support he received from anti-abortion extremist Troy Newman, president of Operation Rescue. Sessions vigorously opposed the 2009 Hate Crimes Prevention Act, particularly concerning given that the attorney general must sign off on all criminal hate crime prosecutions.

Many senators also had concerns over some of his controversial comments. Sessions, who has an alarming record on civil rights, called the Voting Rights Act “intrusive” and has minimized voter suppression tactics in the South. After tapes were released of then-Presidential candidate Trump gloating that he grabs women by the genitals without their consent, Sessions notoriously remarked that he didn’t believe that act of violence legally constituted as sexual assault, a comment that was very concerning to survivors and advocates. The day before Sessions testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee, a group of sexual assault survivors went to Sessions’ Capitol Hill office to present him with the Department of Justice’s definition of sexual assault.

There were also questions about whether he would be willing to stand up to President Trump in the face of potentially illegal or unconstitutional executive actions. Sessions, who has long associated with advocacy groups that promote anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim rhetoric, was reportedly involved in crafting Trump’s controversial Muslim ban.

Sessions’ appointment will be followed by debate over the confirmation of Tom Price for Health and Human Services Secretary and Steven Mnuchin, nominee for Treasury Secretary.

Media Resources: NBC 2/8/17; New York Times 8/7/17; Wall Street Journal 2/9/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 1/11/17, 1/31/17

Betsy DeVos Confirmed as Secretary of the Department of Education

On Tuesday afternoon, Betsy DeVos, one of the most controversial Cabinet nominees of the Trump administration, was confirmed as secretary of the Department of Education, with Vice President Pence making the trip over to the Capitol to break the 50-50 split vote in the Senate.

“This is the first time in American history that a Vice President has ever had to make a tie-breaking vote to confirm a Cabinet nominee, showing just how weak DeVos’s position really is,” said Eleanor Smeal, president of the Feminist Majority Foundation. “Every single Senator who voted “Yes” is personally responsible for the deciding vote, and those of us concerned with equity in education will not soon forget it.”

A billionaire philanthropist whose family has donated over $200 million to Republican politicians, DeVos’s only experience in the realm of education has been her advocacy work concerning the Michigan school system, pushing either for public schools to shut down and privatize in the form of charter schools, or offer all parents vouchers to lessen the costs of sending children to private and religious schools.

DeVos’s initiatives have failed to raise the achievement of disadvantaged students or improve the performance of traditional public schools, with results on national reading and math tests plummeting as charter schools expanded. DeVos has been criticized by supporters of charter schools for creating one of the most unregulated charter school markets in the country; the nation’s most successful charter networks refuse to open schools in Michigan because of the instability. 80 percent of the charter schools in Michigan are operated for-profit, the highest rate of for-profit charter schools in any state in the country.

For weeks, hundreds of thousands of constituents flooded their Senators with calls, letters, visits to their offices, over a million emails, and even faxes. According to Senator Schatz (D-HI), the three days following DeVos’s Committee vote were reportedly the busiest in Capitol switchboard history by almost double. Some Senators were so overwhelmed by the constant barrage of opposition to DeVos that they are now being accused of ignoring their constituents’ pleas.

Parents, teachers, students and education advocates pointed to her catastrophic performance during her Committee hearing, where she displayed a basic lack of knowledge on some of the Education Department’s most important programs, including the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, which guarantees students with disabilities equal access to public education.

She has also consistently failed to support Title IX, donating thousands of dollars to groups that oppose the Office of Civil Right’s guidance on sexual assault, as well as to colleges that are notorious for refusing to comply with Title IX.  When asked in her confirmation hearing whether or not she intended to uphold the Obama administration’s strict 2011 policies surrounding the reporting and investigations of sexual assaults on college campuses, she said an immediate decision on the matter would be “premature.” She went on to voice her support for the Safe Campus Act, which would require sexual assault survivors to file a report with the police if they wanted their school to investigate a sex crime.

In the end only two Republican Senators, Senator Collins of Maine and Senator Murkoswki of Alaska, voted against the confirmation of DeVos. “I have heard from thousands—truly thousands—of Alaskans who shared their concerns about Mrs. DeVos as secretary of education,” Murkowski said on the Senate floor. “They’ve contacted me by phone, by email, in person, and their concerns center, as mine do, on Mrs. DeVos’s lack of experience with public education and the lack of knowledge that she portrayed in her confirmation hearing.”

Both Senator Murkowski and Senator Collins are members of the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions and reported DeVos’s nomination to the Senate floor last week. During that meeting, multiple Senators voiced concerns over reports from the Washington Post that some of DeVos’s written responses submitted the night before were not properly sourced, as some answers appeared to share language with an education magazine article and phrases voiced by other federal nominees, in addition to a response that appears to have been pulled verbatim from a 1979 federal statue.

Still of significant concern is how she intends to divest from her extensive conflicts of interest with her billions of dollars in donations to various causes and her current family business ties. Recent information from her ethics agreements indicate that she doesn’t plan to adequately divest from her holdings in organizations such as Windquest Group, which funds Neurocare , a biomedical company with questionable learning strategies that claims to help children with ADHD.

The Senate now begins the confirmation process for embattled attorney general nominee, Jeff Sessions.

Media Resources: VOX 2/7/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 1/31/17, 1/18/17; The Hill 2/6/17

Boy Scouts Drops Ban on Admitting Transgender Boys

On Monday, The Boy Scouts of America announced that they will no longer be banning transgender boys from entering their program, lifting a century-old policy of exclusion.  Moving forward, the program will base admission off of the gender listed by the child or parent on the application, rather than the sex listed on the child’s birth certificate, as was the practice previously.

The Boy Scouts of America issued a statement, announcing “For more than 100 years, the Boy Scouts of America, along with schools, youth sports and other youth organizations, have ultimately deferred to the information on an individual’s birth certificate to determine eligibility for our single-gender programs. However, that approach is no longer sufficient as communities and state laws are interpreting gender identity differently, and these laws vary widely from state to state.”

This shift in policy follows a recent case in which an eight-year-old transgender boy, Joe Maldonado, from New Jersey was kicked out from his Cub Scout group one month after joining. While his peers and friends were accepting of his gender identity, a number of parents complained to the Boy Scouts of America officials and had him removed, according to the New York Times.

In comparison, Girl Scouts of the USA handles admission of transgender girls on a case-by-case basis”,  so long as “the child is recognized by the family and school/community as a girl and lives culturally as a girl, then Girl Scouts is an organization that can serve her in a setting that is both emotionally and physically safe.”

The Boy Scout’s move to admit transgender boys follows their 2013 decision to admit openly gay children into the program. Prior to 2015, openly gay adults and parents were also unable to participate in Boy Scouts as troop leaders.

Scouts for Equality, a nonprofit organization founded to push Boy Scouts of America (BSA) to embody inclusivity and equality for its members, supported the recent policy change. Justin Wilson, the Executive Director of Scouts for Equality, stated that although the “struggle for the inclusion of lesbian, gay, and bisexual members lasted over 37 years….in stark contrast, a month after the BSA first removed a transgender boy from the program, it has reversed the policy that led to his expulsion.” Wilson called this action “remarkable,” as it displayed the BSA’s willingness to encourage diversity and inclusion amongst its troops.

LGBTQ advocates nationwide are commending the Boy’s Scouts of America’s new standards. Members of the community hope to see the Boy’s Scouts take the next steps in ensuring the policy is embodied in practice, and the matter is approached with healthy conversation and education, and ultimately all members of the program are embraced wholeheartedly.

Media Resources: The Washington Blade 1/30/17, Boy Scouts of America Newsroom 1/30/17, The New York Times 12/30/16, Girl Scouts of the USA FAQ, The New York Times 5/23/13, The New York Times 1/31/17, NBC News 1/31/17; Scouts for Equality 1/31/17

Treasury Secretary Nominee Mnuchin to Have Confirmation Vote this Week

This week the Senate is expected to vote on the nomination of Steve Mnuchin, millionaire businessman, former Goldman Sachs partner and Hollywood film producer, for Treasury Secretary.

Mnuchin has been a contentious nominee because of the many allegations of fraud that have plagued his time in both the banking and film producing industries. In his Senate Finance Committee hearing on January 19th, Mnuchin was questioned in regard to his involvement in a massive wave of foreclosures conducted by OneWest Bank Group, of which Mnuchin was CEO. The bank was accused of engaging in the practice of robo-signing, whereby foreclosure documents are signed en masse without proper review. During this period, Mnuchin was nicknamed the “Foreclosure King” and his institution referred to as “a foreclosure machine.”

After Mnuchin submitted written responses that called the accusations frivolous and false, the Columbus Dispatch released a report in which they analyzed nearly four dozen foreclosure cases in one Ohio county in 2010, finding that the bank had indeed “frequently used robo-signatures.”

“Mnuchin profited off of kicking people out of their homes and then gave false testimony about his bank’s abusive practices,” said Senator Sherrod Brown (D-OH). “He cannot be trusted to make decisions about policies as personal to working Ohioans as their taxes and retirement.”

When Senators found out that they had been deliberately misled by the nominee, the Democratic members of the Finance Committee boycotted the January 31 vote to move forward the nominations of both Mnuchin and nominee for secretary of Health and Human Services, Tom Price, denying the Committee of the required quorum mandating that at least one Senator from each party be present.

Republicans responded the next day by suspending the rules of quorum, and voting to send both nominations to the full Senate for a vote. In a letter to chairman Orrin Hatch, Democratic members explained why they carried out a boycott, stating, “Both nominees have yet to answer important questions that impact the American people. Further, we have significant concerns that both Mr. Mnuchin and Congressman Price gave inaccurate and misleading testimony and responses to questions to the committee. These Cabinet nominees should answer basic questions about their records before we move forward with a committee vote.”

Two days after the Committee vote, new allegations of fraud surfaced in relation to Mnuchin’s former company, Relativity Media. The accusations state Mnuchin was responsible for mismanaging investor funds and failing to notify the investors that the company was clearly failing. The lawsuit brought by RKA Film Financing accuses Mnuchin of using money loaned for advertising expenses, approximately $81 million, for general corporate expenses including salaries, bonuses, and debts. RKA is suing both Mnuchin and his former partner Ryan Kavanaugh for over $110 million in damages.

Despite the allegations of fraud and the Committee delay, Mnuchin will move on to the Senate floor this week for his final confirmation vote. Votes on cabinet nominees DeVos, Sessions, and Price are also expected to take place this week.

Media Resources: USA Today 2/3/2017; CNN 1/31/2017; The Washington Post 2/1/2017; Wall Street Journal 2/3/2017; Feminist Majority Foundation 1/31/17, 2/2/17; LA Times 1/30/17

 

Arkansas Governor Signs Offensive and Dangerous Anti-Abortion Bill

Governor Asa Hutchinson of Arkansas recently signed into law a bill that allows the husband of a woman seeking an abortion to sue his wife’s doctor, either for monetary gain or in order to place an injunction on the procedure, essentially allowing a man to refuse his partner access to an abortion. The new law also bans the most common and safest method for performing a second trimester abortion, essentially blocking all abortions after 14 weeks.

Under the new Unborn Child Protection from Dismemberment Abortion Act, even a husband who is abusive or has raped his wife can legally forbid her from obtaining an abortion, so long as the fetus is biologically his. It also gives the guardians of a minor the right to legally block her from accessing an abortion.

“What that’s getting at, really, is the autonomy and decision-making ability of a woman,” said Laura McQuade, president and CEO of Planned Parenthood Great Plains to The Daily Beast. “The law itself is a major overstep into the doctor-patient relationship…This is taking it one step further to say that women are incapable of making these decisions on their own and on their own behalf.”

Nearly identical laws have been passed in six other states. The courts have struck this law down in all the states where it has been challenged—Louisiana, Alabama, Mississippi, and West Virginia. The ACLU has promised to challenge the new Arkansas law before it is able to go into effect later this year.

Arkansas has a mandatory 48 hour waiting period between a woman’s consultation with her doctor and the time she can access an abortion. There is currently only one clinic in the state that performs the second trimester abortion procedure banned in the new law.

This past September, a U.S. District Court judge issued a preliminary injunction temporarily prohibiting blocks on Medicaid funding for Planned Parenthood after Governor Hutchinson ordered the Arkansas Department of Health Services to defund the healthcare organization.

Ensuring that Arkansas citizens have access to the resources of Planned Parenthood and other women’s health clinics is critical. According to the executive director of the ACLU in Arkansas, Rita Sklar, Arkansas “has the highest teen pregnancy rate in the nation, contribution to the fact that nearly 1 in 5 people live below the poverty level.”

Media Resources: Huffington Post 2/2/17; Daily Beast 2/2/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 10/5/16.

Republicans Suspend Committee Rules to Move Forward with Price Nomination

On Wednesday morning, the Republican controlled Senate Finance Committee suspended the rules of quorum, which require at least one member of each party to be present for a vote, and pushed through Tom Price’s nomination to serve as secretary of Health and Human Services, sending it to the full Senate for a vote. They also voted to move forward with the nomination of Steve Mnuchin for secretary of the Treasury.

The Committee’s chairman Orrin Hatch said, “Long story short we took some unprecedented actions today due to the unprecedented obstruction on the part of our colleagues.”

This bold move came on the second day that Democratic members of the Senate Finance Committee boycotted the vote to move forward with the nominations of Price and Mnuchin, denying the Committee of the required quorum and stopping the vote.

Democratic members sent a letter to Hatch to explain why they chose to boycott the vote, stating, “Both nominees have yet to answer important questions that impact the American people. Further, we have significant concerns that both Mr. Mnuchin and Congressman Price gave inaccurate and misleading testimony and responses to questions to the committee. These Cabinet nominees should answer basic questions about their records before we move forward with a committee vote.”

Democrats accused Price of misleading the Committee, specifically concerning his denial that he purchased of over 400,000 shares of stock in an Australian pharmaceutical company at a discounted price not available to other investors.

Senator Wyden said Tuesday, “I asked Congressman Price directly if he got an exclusive discount on stock in an Australian biomedical firm, and he said no.” Wyden continued, “From the committee’s investigation to company documents to the company officials’ own words, the evidence tells a different story. It looks more and more like Congressman Price got special access to a special deal.” A Finance Committee background investigation found that Price had undervalued those investments and “claimed income tax deductions that he could not substantiate.”

The Department that Price seeks to lead manages an annual budget of over $1 trillion, oversees health insurance of more than 100 million Americans, including setting Medicare policies, controls the agencies that regulate food and drugs, and directs funds to biomedical research. Under this position, he will also be responsible for the Republicans’ plan to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act.

The Senate is expected to vote on his nomination next week.

Resources:  Feminist Majority Foundation 1/31; US News 2/1; Atlanta Journal Constitution 2/1; Huffington Post 1/31/17; Senate Finance Committee 2/1/17

Neil Gorsuch, Dangerous for Women, Nominated to Supreme Court

On Tuesday evening, President Trump announced the nomination of Judge Neil Gorsuch to serve on the Supreme Court. The seat has been open for almost a year following the death of Justice Antonin Scalia and Republicans’ refusal to grant Obama nominee Merrick Garland a hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee.

Judge Gorsuch was appointed to the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver by President George W. Bush, and has experience clerking for two Supreme Court justices. Thought to be even more conservative than Scalia, Gorsuch considers himself to be an originalist, meaning he attempts to interpret the Constitution as it was written by the founders, a fact that leaves many women’s rights activists concerned, as the 19th amendment granting the right to vote is the only explicit Constitutional protection for women.

“The elevation of Judge Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court would be every woman’s and every feminist’s worst nightmare,” said Eleanor Smeal, president of the Feminist Majority. “If Judge Gorsuch’s views should become the majority opinion of the Court, women’s and LGBT rights would be in jeopardy.”

In the infamous Hobby Lobby case, Gorsuch ruled that corporations are people deserving of religious protections and ignored the rights of employed women to access comprehensive healthcare that covers birth control. The Supreme Court later reaffirmed his ruling in the lower court, dismantling one of the most important provisions for women in the Affordable Care Act.

The ruling set a dangerous precedent that corporations could claim religious objections to any regulations they considered too burdensome. This type of imposition could also be legally extended to any individual or corporation who wished to invoke religion to defend discrimination, for example, when firing a transgender employee or a woman who becomes pregnant out of wedlock.

While he does not have a strong record on abortion, it can be inferred from his defense of religious freedom and narrow view of women’s protections under the Constitution, along with Trump’s promise to nominate an anti-abortion judge, that Gorsuch would be complicit in the overturning of Roe V. Wade.

Jessica Mason Pieklo, an adjunct law professor in Boulder, Colorado, wrote in Rewire, “He is a nomination designed to test Democrats’ will to fight, one Trump made in the height of the chaos and protests surrounding his immigration executive order, and as opposition to his cabinet nominees amplified. Trump’s team is counting on Democrats and the public to be overwhelmed and unable to resist each executive overreach and crony cabinet choice.”

Media Resources: New York Times 1/31/17; Rewire 2/1/17; Cosmopolitan 2/1/17

>