Sanctuary Cities Saved by Federal Judge

On Tuesday a District Court judge in San Francisco temporarily blocked President Trump’s January executive order threatening to pull federal funding from sanctuary cities who do not comply with the administration’s mass deportation efforts.

The judge ruled that Trump did not have the authority to make funding for all grants and programs conditional on compliance with the single issue of immigration enforcement, saying that power belonged to Congress. The Supreme Court has already ruled that the federal government cannot force states to comply with federal programs, and the 10th amendment requires that the federal funds at stake must be associated with the exact policy in question.

While the lawyers from the Justice Department tried to argue that Trump did not intend to withhold significant amounts of federal funding from sanctuary cities, the judge said that the president and attorney general’s public statements on the matter contradicted the government’s argument.

The judge’s ruling is temporarily in place nationwide until he can reach a larger decision on the order’s constitutionality, though he implied that the final decision was likely to grant a victory to the plaintiffs.

“This is why we have courts—to halt the overreach of a president and an attorney general who either don’t understand the Constitution or chose to ignore it,” said Dennis Herrera, the attorney for San Francisco city. “Because San Francisco took this president to court, we’ve been able to protect billions of dollars that fund lifesaving programs across this country.”

Sanctuary city is a broad term with no exact definition, but the general consensus among them is a declaration by local authorities that they will not comply with oppressive federal immigration crackdowns. That means that they will largely not cooperate in raids, turn over undocumented immigrants who are arrested on minor charges, or allow police to ask individuals about their immigration status.

San Francisco argued that by trying to deputize local officers to act as immigration agents, the administration was threatening public safety by breaking trust between law enforcement and the community they are meant to serve. Immigrants documented and not, would be less likely to report crimes or assist in investigations.

San Francisco and Santa Clara County filed suit after they estimated they could lose over $1 billion and $1.7 billion in federal funding respectively. Since then, five other local governments have also filed suit and others have said they will do so if Trump attempts to follow through with the executive order.

A report by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) found that of the 168 counties where most of the 11 million undocumented immigrants live, 69 have declined the administration’s request to detain people based on immigration status while 99 counties have accepted to the federal request.

Trump has encountered a number of judicial setbacks to his immigration orders, most significantly the temporary blocks of his travel ban on people from seven, and later revised to six, Muslim majority countries.

Media Resources: New York Times 4/25/17; Washington Post 4/26/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 2/1/17

Anti-Abortion Group Files Lawsuit Against Removal of Virginia Abortion Restriction

Last week the Family Foundation filed a lawsuit opposing amendments to Virginia’s “Regulations for Licensure of Abortion Facilities” that removed unconstitutional outpatient surgical center building requirements imposed on clinics that perform abortions.

The Virginia Board of Health had approved the amendments in October by a vote of 11-4 and Governor Terry McAuliffe had certified the changes in January. The rules went into effect March 22 and put Virginia in compliance with the Supreme Court decision in the Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt case, which classified surgical center building requirements as an undue burden on abortion providers.

According to NARAL Pro-Choice Virginia, the Family Foundation waited until the public comment period was over to announce that they’d be filing a lawsuit.

“The lawsuit is another desperate attempt by anti-abortion groups to cut off a Virginia woman’s access to safe, legal abortion anyway they can,” said Tarina Keene, executive director of NARAL Pro-Choice Virginia.

The struggle over these burdensome targeted restrictions on abortion providers (TRAP) began in 2011 when the state passed a law requiring clinics to widen their hallways and doorways, expand their parking lots, and construct awnings at the entrances, forcing clinics to either pay unnecessary costs or close.

The Virginia Board of Health was responsible for carrying out that law, and in 2013 the Board voted to only impose the medically unnecessary requirements on new clinics. Then-state Attorney General and strong abortion opponent Ken Cuccinelli responded by saying he would not defend the Board if they were sued over that decision and threatened that Board members could be held personally legally liable, causing them to reverse their vote. Their decision to amend those regulations in October was a major victory for advocates of women’s reproductive rights.

In February, Governor McAuliffe vetoed a bill that would have specifically cut off Title X funding to organizations that perform abortions. The Delegate who introduced the bill is hoping that the General Assembly will be able to override the Governor’s veto.

Media Resources: NARAL Pro-Choice Virginia 4/21/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 2/23/17, 10/25/16

Three Texas Voting Laws Ruled Racially Discriminatory

Last week, a three judge panel ruled 2-1 that a Texas statehouse redistricting plan crafted by the state legislature was unconstitutional as it purposely sought to weaken minority votes.

U.S District Judges Xavier Rodriguez and Orlando Garcia wrote, “Discussions among map drawers demonstrated a hostility to creating any new minority districts as those were seen to be a loss of Republican seats, despite the massive minority population growth statewide.”

The House redistricting committee, made up of 12 Republicans and 5 Democrats, targeted the urban counties of Dallas, El Paso, Tarrant, Harris and Bexar, drawing the districts in such a way that protected Republican incumbents and violated Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act and the Fourteenth Amendment. The court said that the “bizarre” shapes of some counties could only be explained by an intention to weaken Latino votes.

In addition, the map did not grant equal representation, violating the “one person, one vote” rule, as some districts were drawn with larger populations than others.

Just last month this same panel of federal judges determined that Texas’s congressional maps, also redrawn in 2011, were unconstitutional and discriminated against minority voters. The ruling stated that the redistricting plan “intentionally drew a district based on race in a location where such use of race was not justified by a compelling state interest.”

Both rulings can be appealed to the Supreme Court, and the plaintiffs in the cases can request that the state be placed under federal supervision when passing future election laws.

Two weeks ago, Judge Nelva Gonzales Ramos of the United States District Court for the Southern District of Texas ruled for the second time that Texas’s 2011 voter ID law was passed with the intent to discriminate against black and Hispanic voters. After he had come to this decision the first time, the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, the most conservative federal appeals court in the country, ruled that the law was racially discriminatory and disproportionately hindered people of color, but sent the case back down to Ramos to rehear the argument of intent to discriminate. His decision two weeks ago reaffirmed that claim.

The law required individuals to show a limited selection of government issued photo identification when they went to vote. The approved IDs included military IDs and concealed handgun carry permits, but forbade employee photo IDs and university photo IDs. The law was found to purposely privilege forms of identification that were more likely to be held by white voters and excluded those more likely to belong to people of color.

In February, Attorney General Jeff Sessions withdrew the Obama era objection to Texas’s draconian voter ID law, but the case proceeded because there were many other parties involved in the lawsuit including Texas voters who had actively been denied the right to vote.

Texas had been one of the states whose election laws were under federal supervision under the Voting Rights Act of 1965. In 2013, the Supreme Court overturned the provision requiring specific states to seek federal approval, freeing Texas to pass whatever election laws it pleased. Voting rights activists have stated that if that provision of the Voting Rights Act was still in place, Texas taxpayers would have been spared the significant legal costs incurred defending these unconstitutional laws.

Media Resources: Dallas Morning News 4/21/17; NPR 3/11/17; CNN 3/12/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 2/28; Vice 4/21/17

 

Illinois Considers Ratifiying the ERA

On Tuesday, April 25th the Illinois state Senate will consider bill SJRCA 4, the state ratification for the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) to the U.S. Constitution. This same day, a coalition of progressive advocates plan to march on the capital of Springfield, in the spirit of the January 21 Women’s Marches, to advocate for legislation being considered in the spring 2017 legislative session, including the ERA ratification.

The ERA states: “Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of sex.”

The measure passed the Illinois Senate in 2014 by a vote of 39 to 11 but was never put up for a vote in the House. Supporters are hopeful that it’s hearing in the Subcommittee on Constitutional Amendments on Tuesday will once again help propel the provision forward. In order for it to be ratified by Illinois, 3/5ths of the Legislature must vote in favor.

The ERA passed both houses of the United States Congress in 1972, and like every proposed amendment to the U.S. Constitution was sent to the states for ratification. The amendment lost momentum after the arbitrary ten year deadline set by Congress for its passage came in 1982. The movement was three states short of the 38 needed for ratification. But the push for the ERA has received renewed attention following the election of Donald Trump.

In March, Nevada became the 36th state and the first state since 1982 to ratify the ERA. The formalities of the ratification procedure were successfully concluded on March 22, the 45th anniversary of when the U.S. Senate approved the ERA and forwarded it to the states for ratification in 1972.

Many Constitutional scholars believe that because the time-limit is in the pre-amble of the amendment, and therefore not voted on by the states, it is subject to extension by a vote in Congress. Thousands demonstrated in Washington in 1978, and Congress granted an extension until June 30, 1982.

The ERA’s passage would be far from simply symbolic; it will help women in cases of discrimination in education, employment, wages, insurance benefits, scholarships, military service, social security, violence against women, and so much more. Without the passage of the ERA, women have been forced to gain equality law by law. If the ERA was ratified by 38 states and became the law of the land, there would be a Constitutional provision against the Supreme Court, Congress or state legislatures gutting equality on the basis of sex.

The efforts to ratify the ERA are part of a grassroots campaign strategy that rejects the time-limit on the fight for equality. In October the Durham City Council unanimously passed a resolution calling on the North Carolina state legislature to ratify the ERA. In addition to Nevada, North Carolina and Illinois, the 12 other states that originally failed to ratify the ERA are Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Utah and Virginia.

Media Resources: Illinois Women’s March on Springfield; Illinois General Assembly; Chicago Sun Times 4/3/17; Feminist Majority Foundation

Advocates Demand DeVos Respect Title IX

On Friday, advocates and survivors of sexual assault went to the Department of Education to demand that Secretary DeVos listen to their concerns about the continuation and enforcement of Title IX, which promises freedom from sex discrimination in order to achieve equal access to education.

Activists, led by The Action Network, are calling on DeVos to commit to protecting survivors by enforcing Title IX. They are also asking her to uphold the guidance for all students, including trans and disabled students, and to hire appropriate legal counsel with track records that demonstrate support for survivors.

This week, the Education Department hired Candice Jackson to be the new secretary for civil rights. Jackson is a critic of feminism and programs that aim to assist people of color, and she has called the women who accused President Trump of sexual violence “fake victims.” This is the woman now in charge of enforcing Title IX and protecting victims of sexual assault.

“It bothers me most if Secretary DeVos is going to really dumb down Title IX enforcement,” said former Vice President Joe Biden, a passionate advocate for sexual assault prevention. “The real message, the real frightening message you’re going to send out is, our culture says it’s OK. You know, the major reason why women drop out of college when they’re a freshman is because of sexual assault. Not their grades, sexual assault. And so, it would be devastating.”

Throughout her time as a philanthropist focused on education—her only experience relevant to the office she now holds—DeVos consistently failed to support Title IX. Instead, her family has supported Grove City College, an institution notorious for refusing to comply with Title IX. DeVos herself has given thousands of dollars to the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE), a group that has actively opposed the Department of Education’s guidance on sexual assault and has sought to make it more difficult for survivors to prove sexual misconduct in school grievance hearings.

When asked in her confirmation hearing whether she intended to uphold the Department’s guidance concerning sexual assault on college campuses, DeVos said an immediate decision on the matter would be “premature.” She went on to voice her support for the Safe Campus Act, a bill that would require sexual assault survivors to file a report with the police if they wanted their school to investigate a sex crime. The bill, supported by FIRE, was so extreme that groups representing fraternities and sororities had to backtrack on their early support of the bill because of student outcry.

DeVos has already helped the President remove Title IX protections for transgender students. In February, she signed onto a joint letter with the Department of Justice claiming that Obama had not sought proper legal analysis or provided appropriate explanation when he expanded Title IX to protect transgender students and stipulated that a provision of that would be to allow students to use whichever restroom corresponded to their gender identity.

Her letter led to the Supreme Court sending the case of transgender student Gavin Grimm back down to the appeal’s court for reconsideration, refusing to hear the case in light of Trump and DeVos’s rescinding of Title IX protections for transgender students. The lawsuit in question had been filed against the Gloucester County School Board on behalf of 17 year old transgender student Gavin Grimm after he was barred from using the boys’ restroom at his Virginia high school. His lawyers argued the discriminatory bathroom policy was a violation of Title IX.

 

Media Resources: Teen Vogue 4/17/17; Huffington Post 4/14/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 2/15/17, 3/6/17

Bill O’Reilly is Out

Bill O’Reilly has been forced out of Fox News after widespread national condemnation over sexual harassment allegations led to more than 70 companies pulling their advertisements from The O’Reilly Factor.

O’Reilly was sent away with a $25 million payout, significantly more than was ever paid to any of the five women who received settlements after being harassed and abused by O’Reilly. Those five settlements totaled a mere $13 million combined.

While the public only knows of six women who received settlements, there are many others who allege being sexually harassed by O’Reilly who never sought out legal reconciliation.

Former Fox News CEO Roger Ailes was ousted 9 months ago with a $40 million severance package after former news anchor Gretchen Carlson found a way around Fox’s secret arbitration clause, publicly exposing Ailes as an accused serial sexual harasser and abuser.  Many of Fox’s contracts contain fine print that forfeit an employee’s right to have a legal dispute with the company settled in court, instead forcing them into private proceedings that typically result in significantly lower payouts and keep sexual harassment allegations secret.

While 21st Century Fox claims that O’Reilly’s ousting is evidence of the corporate cultural shift they’ve promised following the ousting of Ailes, many inside the company are skeptical, pointing to the continued employment of Ailes’ top lieutenants, Bill Shine and Jack Abernethy, as signs that 21st Century Fox’s claims are disingenuous.

Despite having to settle at least six cases of sexual harassment, O’Reilly’s contract had been renewed earlier this year for an additional four years. Between 2014 and 2016, The O’Reilly Factor generated more than $446 million in advertising revenue.

A leading figurehead of the right-wing movement, O’Reilly’s career was one filled with racist, misogynistic and violent rhetoric. Over a four year period, O’Reilly notoriously dedicated 29 episodes of his show to vilifying abortion provider Dr. George Tiller. O’Reilly called him “Tiller the Baby Killer” and accused him of “operating a death mill.” He once said, “And if I could get my hands on Tiller—well, you know. Can’t be vigilantes. Can’t do that. It’s just a figure of speech. But despicable? Oh, my God. Oh, it doesn’t get worse. Does it get worse? No.”

Tiller was shot to death in his church in 2009 by an anti-abortion extremist.

Bill O’Reilly exhibited violent tendencies and abuse of women in his personal life as well, with documented reports of violence towards his wife, witnessed by their children. His teenage daughter reported that she once saw her father dragging her mother down the stairs by her neck. O’Reilly told his daughter that her mother was an “adulterer.”

O’Reilly has denied all accusations made by the women he has worked with, his ex-wife and his daughter.

Media Resources: New York Times 4/20/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 4/11/17; Alternet 4/19/17; Rolling Stones 4/20/17; Gawker 5/20/15.

Women’s Health Protection Act Introduced in Congress

In early March, a women’s health bill entitled the Women’s Health Protection Act of 2017 was introduced to the Senate Judiciary Committee. First introduced in 2013, the bill aims to protect the rights of women to access abortion services on the federal level. In the Senate, the bill is sponsored by Senator Richard Blumenthal (D-CT) and co-sponsored by 40 other Democratic and Independent senators.

The text of the bill states that “access to safe, legal abortion services is essential to women’s health and central to women’s ability to participate equally in the economic and social life of the United States.” The bill makes state “TRAP laws” illegal, including requirements that require individuals looking to obtain an abortion to undergo unnecessary medical tests and in-person visits prior to the procedure.

The need for this bill comes from a history of state laws that create obstacles for individuals looking to obtain a safe and legal abortion. TRAP (Targeted Regulation of Abortion Providers) laws impose unnecessary and burdensome regulations on abortion providers that make accessing an abortion challenging. According to research by the Guttmacher Institute, 18 states require abortion clinics to meet the standards for surgical centers in order to meet licensing requirements. Additionally, 17 states have laws that lay out specific requirements for procedure rooms, hallways, and neighboring facilities including the dimensions of corridors and procedure rooms and proximity to a hospital. The Guttmacher Institute states that these regulations “do little to improve patient care but that set standards that may be impossible for providers to meet.”

From 2011 through 2013, some 178 abortion restrictions were passed by state legislatures and signed into law. These are the highest numbers since the Roe v. Wade decision in 1973. According to NARAL Pro-Choice America, 45 states and the District of Columbia have laws subjecting abortion providers to burdensome restrictions not imposed on other medical professions.

An identical version of the bill has been introduced to the House of Representatives by Rep. Judy Chu (D-CA), Rep. Marcia Fudge (D-OH) and Rep. Lois Frankel (D-FL). The bill seeks to enforce the decision from the 2016 Supreme Court case Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt, in which two provisions of a Texas law requiring abortion providers to have admitting privileges at a local hospital were ruled an unconstitutional undue burden on women seeking an abortion.

Resources: Congress.gov; FMF 11/15/2013; Act for Women; Guttmacher Institute 4/15/2017; SCOTUS Blog

Trump Adviser Stephen Miller Placed In Charge of Women’s Issues

Last week Politico announced that President Trump’s senior advisor Stephen Miller will be working alongside Ivanka Trump on women’s issues, including family leave and childcare policy.

The 31-year old speech writer has no experience working on women’s issues, and many women’s rights advocates have pointed to an article he once wrote denying the existence of the gender wage gap and opposing paid maternity leave as reason for concern over his appointment.

In an opinion piece titled “Sorry feminists”, Miller cites the gap as a product of less hours worked by women compared to men, placing the blame on women’s choice of “lower-paying professions” with “fewer hazards.” He claims that “in modern-day America, there is a place for gender roles,” for if we close the gap many men will be forced give up a “noble career.”

“The image of Stephen Miller, a well-documented misogynist, headed up the White House’s ‘women’s issues’ department would be laughable if it wasn’t so horrifying,” commented EMILY’s List President Stephanie Schriok.

The popular citation regarding the wage gap is that a woman makes 79 cents for every man’s dollar, but taking other social divisions into consideration reveals that minority women have it much worse. For every dollar a white man earns, African American women make only 63 cents, Native American women make 58 cents, and Latinas make 54. Lesbian women make less than both gay and heterosexual men, and trans women make much less following transition. Disabled women make 3 cents less than disabled men, and mothers make 71 cents for every dollar paid to a father.

This loss of pay will go on to affect women for the rest of their lives. “Lower pay throughout their working lives also means that women contribute less to retirement plans, receive lower pensions and lower Social Security benefits,” states Joint Economic Committee Ranking Member Carolyn Maloney.

The result of this is that women 75 years and older are twice as likely to live in poverty than their male counterparts. Women of color experience poverty on a particularly high scale, with one in five living in poverty overall, and three in five who are living alone live in poverty.

On April 4th, the day before Equal Pay Day, the President revoked an Obama-era executive order requiring companies with federal contracts to follow wage transparency clause, including informing employees of specific deductions, rate of pay and total hours worked so that female employees feel empowered to make sure they are being paid the same as their male coworkers.

The revoked order also banned companies with federal contracts from putting in contracts forced arbitration clauses in cases of sexual harassment or discrimination.

Media Resources: Politico 4/13/17; The Huffington Post 4/14/17; The Duke Chronicle 11/22/2005; Economic Policy Institute 7/20/16; National Women’s Law Center 9/19/16; US Congress Joint Economic Committee 4/08/16; Feminist Majority Foundation 4/7/17

Afghanistan Now Has 260 Female Judges

The head of the Afghan Women Judges’ Association, Shakila Abawi Shagarf, announced last month that there are now 260 female judges in Afghanistan as of this year. While the majority—225—are in the capital of Kabul, there are 21 in Harat province, 11 in Balkh province, two in Takhar province and one in Baghlan province. During the Taliban regime that fell sixteen years ago, there were no female judges.

While the progress has been strong, Shagarf lamented, “There should be at least one judge in the superior judiciary and at least on woman should also be present in the selection board of the Supreme Court.” She continued, “This would be an important step forward that would pave way for justice and equality in the country.”

Afghan President Ashraf Ghani has not yet fulfilled a campaign promise to put a woman on the country’s nine-member Supreme Court. In 2015, he nominated Judge Anisa Rasooli to serve on the Court, but she fell 9 votes shy of the 97 votes needed to put her on the bench. 23 of the 69 female lawmakers in the Afghan parliament didn’t even turn out for the vote.

Despite the persistent Taliban terrorist attacks, Afghanistan is a nation that continues to make considerable progress, especially for women. The maternal mortality rate has fallen dramatically and women’s athletic clubs have become popular social activities. Women are being encouraged to take roles in STEM work, and some 80% of Afghan women now have regular or occasional access to mobile phones and

Media Resources: The Peninsula 3/30/17; Washington Post 7/17/15; Tolo 6/14/15, 3/29/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 12/20/16

Trump Administration Cuts Off All UNFPA Funding

Earlier this month—right after the Republican-controlled Congress approved a repeal of an Obama-era regulation that reinforced protections for healthcare access under the Title X family planning program—the Trump Administration officially cut off all US funding for the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA), the main UN agency working to advance family planning worldwide.

The US Department of State, citing the Kemp-Kasten Amendment, notified Congress of the decision on April 3. The Kemp-Kasten Amendment, included in annual appropriations legislation, prohibits funding of organizations that “support or participate in the management of a program of coercive abortion or involuntary sterilization.” According to the State Department, UNFPA’s country program in China was in violation of the amendment. Yet, in its own two-page justification of the Administration’s decision, the State Department notes that although UNFPA partners with China’s National Health and Family Planning Commission, there is “no evidence that UNFPA directly engages in coercive abortion or involuntary sterilizations in China,” a conclusion also reached by the George W. Bush State Department after a two-week fact-finding mission to China in 2002. That fact-finding mission found no evidence that UNFPA “knowingly supported or participated” in any such activities, according to PAI, a global reproductive health organization.

PAI called the Trump Administration’s justification of its decision to terminate funding, “a wholly unconvincing argument in support of a politically-motivated decision to cut off UNFPA.”

In a statement, UNFPA called the Trump Administration’s portrayal of its China program “erroneous,” and asserted that “all of its work promotes the human rights of individuals and couples to make their own decisions, free of coercion or discrimination.” It continued, “Indeed, United Nations Member States have long described UNFPA’s work in China as a force for good.”

The Trump Administration’s decision means that the US will withhold at least $32.5 million from UNFPA, representing the US voluntary core contribution. PAI notes, however, that the Kemp-Kasten Amendment applies to any funds provided in the State Department and foreign operation appropriations bill, which affects funding provided to UNFPA from refugee, humanitarian, or disaster accounts included in the bill. All in, UNFPA stands to lose about $71 million: $32.5 million core contribution plus $38 million for reproductive and maternal health services in humanitarian settings.

Notably, the cut in funding threatens to have the most impact in UNFPA’s work outside of China, where UNFPA spends relatively little money. Instead, according to Melissa Kuklin, Executive Director of Washington, DC-based Friends of UNFPA, the funding cut will likely impact UNFPA’s ability to provide refugee services, for example, to Syrian refugees in Jordan who receive not only UNFPA-provided maternal health services, but also psychological support, especially important for survivors of gender-based violence. UNFPA is considered a lead agency for gender-based violence prevention around the world.

“The US defunding of UNFPA is senseless and shortsighted,” commented Katja Iverson, President and CEO of Women Deliver, a global health organization for women and girls. “It will cost lives and money, while contributing to a more unequal and unstable world.”

The US is one of the largest donors to UNFPA. According to the agency, US funding in FY 2016 helped allow UNFPA to prevent 947,000 unintended pregnancies; 295,000 unsafe abortions; and 2,340 maternal deaths.

Media Resources: Kaiser Family Foundation 4/17/17; NPR 4/4/17; PAI Washington Memo 4/4/17; UNFPA Press Release 4/4/17; Buzzfeed 4/3/17; Women Deliver; Feminist Newswire 3/31/17

White House Will No Longer Release Visitors’ Logs

Last week, President Trump quietly announced that his administration will stop the Obama-era practice of releasing the White House visitor logs to the public, claiming it is a matter of national security.

This means that the revolving door of lobbyists, activists, and political donors coming to meet with the President and his senior staff will be kept secret, granting anonymity to those who supposedly have the most face time and influence with the administration.

Government watch dog groups were outraged over Trump’s flippant disregard for transparency, calling the national security argument “a falsehood,” and pointing to Obama’s practice of not releasing the names of officials attending high-profile intelligence meetings. Many are arguing that the move to withhold all visitors’ names is a blatant attempt to hide something from the public.

Before the White House’s announcement, the National Security Archive, Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), and the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University all filed lawsuits to gain access to visitors’ logs under the Freedom of Information Act. These groups wanted to see the visitors not just to the White House, but also to Trump Tower in New York as well as Mar-a-Lago in Palm Beach where Trump frequently conducts official White House business.

There is debate over whether or not the visitors’ logs are subject to Freedom of Information Act requests. Some, including the Obama administration, claimed they were not because they are White House records. Other’s claim the logs are able to be requested because they are kept by the Secret Service, a governmental agency subject to the law.

Under the Presidential Records Act, the public will not be able to gain access to the President’s visitors’ logs requests until five years after the end of the administration.

A court ruled in 2011 that it is not against the law for the White House to withhold the names of visitors, though the Obama administration continued to release them, disclosing over six million White House visitor records during his terms. The Obama administration did make exceptions for some people, such as private guests of the first family or those coming to be interviewed for Supreme Court nominations.

Trump’s visitors’ logs gained increased attention recently after it was discovered that House Intelligence Committee Chairman Devin Nunes secretly went to the White House to view so-called “evidence” that Trump campaign associates were accidentally recorded during counter-intelligence surveillance of foreign targets. It later came out that the FBI had obtained at least one FISA warrant to directly surveil Trump campaign associate and suspected Russian collaborator, Carter Paige, proving either Nunes’s evidence or explanation false.  Nunes has since recused himself from the investigation into Russian interference.

This latest abandonment of transparency norms by the President came the day before the nationwide Tax March, when people took to the streets to demand Trump release his tax returns. Before becoming President, Trump notoriously chastised Obama for not releasing his birth certificate and college transcripts, accusing him of “hiding something.”

 

Media Resources: New York Time 4/14/17; The Hill 4/10/17; Chicago Tribune 4/17/17

New Report Details Trouble With California’s Charter Schools

A report released this month by the research and policy center In The Public Interest details the educational shortcomings and financial wastes of California’s charter school industry, a warning to other states, and the federal government, considering implementing similar policies.

The report describes how charter schools have wasted hundreds of millions of dollars in state funding and tax subsidies by building nearly a third of California’s charter schools in communities where there was no demand, and frequently offering an education that was of a much lower caliber than the area’s public schools. Over the last 15 years, the state has spent over $2.5 billion just on leasing, building and buying charter school buildings.

Typically, school districts receive money to build additional schools only if the five year population growth estimate of the county shows that the district will not be able to meet demand for public education in five years with the current supply. However, the same rule does not apply to charter schools.

In addition, the report found that three-quarters of the state’s 1,200 charter schools provide an education that is not superior to the one offered in that community’s public school, meaning that nearly $2 billion in California funding and financing were unnecessarily wasted on institutions that provide a low quality education.

Over 30 percent of California charter schools were determined to be both failing and in a community with no need for additional educational resources. Meanwhile, public schools in need of funding are going without.

The report states, “Because legislators’ vision for charter schools has not been incorporated into funding formulas, the hundreds of millions of dollars spent annually on charter facilities have not created the hoped for incubator of innovation and continual improvement. While some charter schools have proved exemplary, much of the industry has become dominated by the same types of organizations legislators had sought to reform: large chains of schools where materials, methods, and evaluation are centrally dictated and teachers lack the power to set the curriculum; Charter Management Organizations (CMOs) that replicate a single model over and over again with little variation; and schools whose quality of education is no better than that of nearby public schools, and who do not serve to spur improvements in the wider system.”

The report is troubling considering Trump’s Education Secretary Betsy DeVos is an avid defender of unregulated charter schools and a voucher system. As a billionaire philanthropist in Michigan, she advocated either for public schools to shut down and privatize in the form of charter schools, or offer all parents vouchers to lessen the cost of sending children to private and religious schools.

Like in California, DeVos’s initiatives to implement charter schools in Michigan have failed to raise the advancement of disadvantaged students or improve the performance of traditional public schools, with results on national reading and math tests plummeting as charter schools expanded. In 2015, a federal review found “an unreasonably high” percentage of charter schools fell into the list of Michigan’s lowest performing schools. 80 percent of charter schools in Michigan are operated for-profit, the highest rate of for-profit charter schools in any state in the country.

When a bill was introduced that would have placed basic regulations and oversights over charter schools, DeVos withheld financial support from Republican lawmakers until they killed the measure, arguing that the free market should be the only regulator of education.

DeVos has been criticized by supporters of charter schools for creating one of the most unregulated charter school markets in the country; the nation’s most successful charter networks refuse to open schools in Michigan because of the instability. Because there is no limit on the number of charter schools that can be opened, more than 150 schools have opened or closed in Detroit in the last seven years, with too many seats available in downtown schools and not nearly enough in the poorest, most remote neighborhoods.

A recent report found that the expansion of charter schools in US cities is “exacerbating inequalities across schools and children because children are being increasingly segregated by economic status, race, language, and disabilities and further, because charter schools are raising and spending vastly different amounts, without regard for differences in student needs.”

Media Resources: In The Public Interest 04/2017; Feminist Majority Foundation 2/7/17, 1/18/17

Persecution of Gay Men in Chechnya Escalates

Reports are coming out of Chechnya that a large group of gay men are being held by the government in concentration camps and have been subjected to violent interrogations.

Human Rights Watch has reported that one of these concentration camp prisons is located at a former military base approximately 19 kilometers outside Grozny, the capital of Chechnya.

Just last week reports of an alleged round-up of gay men in the former Russian territory of Chechnya sparked international outrage. The Novaya Gazeta, a Russian newspaper, reported last week that they had evidence to prove that Chechen authorities targeted and apprehended 100 gay men. The same report states that during the “round up” at least 3 men were killed.  Although the allegations only come from one source, human rights activists in the region report that they have heard similar rumors over the past few weeks.

Tanya Lokshina of Human Rights Watch wrote in an online statement that “It is difficult to overstate just how vulnerable LGBT people are in Chechnya, where homophobia is intense and rampant.”

Chechnya, a republic of Russia, is known as a highly conservative Muslim state under the leadership of current President Ramzan Kadyrov. Kadyrov has been criticized by human rights activists for encouraging polygamy, passing laws that force women to wear hijabs in public, and subjecting members of the LGBTQ community to discrimination and even violence.

Although the Chechan government has not yet released a statement concerning the most recent allegations, they did release a statement when rumors of the round up began. The spokesperson for Kadyrov stated that the accusations made by the Novaya Gazeta were “absolute lies” and went on to claim that “you cannot detain and persecute people who simply do not exist in the republic.”

American based human rights groups are calling upon the newly appointed secretary of state, Rex Tillerson, to speak out against Chechnya’s human rights violations in targeting members of the LGBTQ community. Similarly, Members of the European Parliament are calling upon UK Prime Minister Theresa May and Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson to call a meeting with the Russian ambassador and condemn the actions of the Chechan government.

 

Media Resources: PinkNews 4/12/17, 4/10/17; Huffingotn Post 4/11/17; Telegraph 4/11/17; Human Rights Watch 4/4/17; FMF 4/3/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 4/3/17

American University of Afghanistan Has Reopened Following Terrorist Attack

The American University of Afghanistan (AUAF) in Kabul has recently reopened after being close for seven months following a terror attack that left at least thirteen dead including seven students and one professor.

“The attackers wanted to permanently close this excellent center of learning. They failed,” said Zalmay Khalilzad, former U.S. Ambassador to Afghanistan and current member of the university’s Board of Trustees. “I wish the AUAF success in delivering on its mission: to educate its students and provide them with 21st century skills, who can lead successful lives and, in turn, can help Afghanistan succeed.”

In August, armed militants stormed the grounds of the university at around 7pm Kabul time, trapping approximately 160 people inside the buildings during a ten hour siege. Two attackers were eventually shot and killed by security forces.

Security has increased in the wake of the attack; the height of the boundary wall has nearly doubled and gun towers and checkpoints are now run by armed guards. In addition, student orientation focused heavily on security training.

The attack has not deterred 80 new students from enrolling in the university this semester, increasing the number of attendees to 1,700 students, the highest number in a year ever for the school. Despite many international organizations pulling staff out of the country amid security concerns, the university says that many foreign faculty members have chosen to stay.

The university, which opened in 2006, is located in the center of Kabul, and frequently receives assistance and high praise from American dignitaries, including former first lady Laura Bush who has raised substantial money for the school.

The school has been a target for militants who oppose American intervention in Afghanistan and the education of women and girls. A few weeks prior to the attack, two professors from the university, an American and an Australian, were kidnapped at gunpoint from their vehicle near the campus by men dressed as members of the Afghan security forces. They are still missing.

The United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan’s 2016 report showed an increase in conflict related civilian casualties to the highest recorded number since 2009. According to the report, attacks by anti-government forces, most significantly the Taliban, accounted for 61 percent of the civilian casualties, with casualties caused by ISIS increasing by ten times in 2016.

 

Media Resources: VOA 3/26/17; Times Higher Education 4/11/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 8/26/16, 2/13/17; Reuters 3/27/17

More Sexual Harassment Allegations Plague Fox as Advertisers Flee

Ten days ago, the New York Times broke a story about five women to whom 21st Century Fox has paid out around $13 million to address allegations of abuse and sexual harassment at the hands of Fox News star, Bill O’Reilly. In addition to these five women who reached settlements, there have been at least two more who also allege sexual harassment on the part of O’Reilly.

According to the report, these women all either worked for O’Reilly or appeared on his show. They allege a variety of inappropriate behaviors ranging from lewd comments to unwanted advances, and all depict a predatory pattern of O’Reilly using his power and influence in an attempt to manipulate or extort these women for sex.

Despite these continuous allegations of sexual harassment, Bill O’Reilly has retained his show on the Fox News Network. Between 2014 and 2016, The O’Reilly Factor generated more than $446 million in advertising revenues.

In response to nationwide horror over the allegations against O’Reilly, over 70 companies have pulled their advertisements from his program. Still he remains on air, with ratings higher than before the scandal broke.

Last week, at the beginning of Sexual Assault Awareness Month, President Trump defended O’Reilly saying he was a “good person” and stated, “I don’t think Bill did anything wrong.” The President, who frequently endorses Fox News and Bill O’Reilly, was infamously embroiled in his own controversy after a 2005 tape was released in which he described grabbing women by the genitals without their consent. He dismissed criticisms surrounding that incident by referring to his comments as “locker room talk.”

O’Reilly claims that the allegations are without merit while 21st Century Fox insists that they have “addressed the issue.” Two of the sexual harassment suits reported in the Times were settled after the departure of disgraced former Fox News CEO Roger Ailes, an accused serial abuser who was sent away with a $40 million severance package. President Trump also defended Roger Ailes while that controversy was unfolding.

As the public learned from former Fox News host Gretchen Carlson in 2016, many of Fox’s contracts contain arbitration clauses, fine print that forfeits an employee’s right to have a legal dispute with their company settled in court, instead forcing them into private proceedings. The proceedings are overseen by an arbiter or a judge but lack a public trial by jury and typically result in significantly lower settlements for the plaintiff. Arbitration clauses have been criticized as ways for major corporations to suppress their employee’s options for legal recourse and keep sexual harassment allegations secret.

The Supreme Court has ruled that sexual harassment constitutes a form of sex discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Under Title VII, Bill O’Reilly cannot be personally held liable for federal sex discrimination, though he could be open to criminal prosecution should he commit a crime such as assault or rape. In the case of Gretchen Carlson, she sued Roger Ailes under a state’s anti-discrimination laws. Typically, it is the employer who is sued in these federal cases where the plaintiff must prove that the company is liable for the harassers behavior.

Legal experts say O’Reilly has put 21st Century Fox in a difficult position moving forward, as it will be very difficult for the company to argue they have done everything possible to create a non-hostile work environment for women.

25 percent of women report experiencing sexual harassment in the work place, and false reports are exceptionally rare. Only 15 percent of federal discrimination complaints end in a successful finding for the plaintiff, a lower win rate than all other forms of civil lawsuits.

Media Resources: New York Times 4/1/17, 4/5/17; Think Progress 4/10/17; Vox 4/11/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 10/26/16.

Police Reform for Baltimore Despite Sessions’ Attempts to Block

Last week a federal judge in Baltimore finalized a reform agreement, known as a consent decree, between the local police department and the Department of Justice (DOJ) despite condemnation and disapproval by Attorney General Jeff Sessions.

The judge’s approval came despite Sessions’ attempts to delay the decree for at least 30 days so that it could be reviewed. US District Judge James Bredar responded, “The time for negotiating the agreement is over. The only question now is whether the Court needs more time to consider the proposed decree. It does not.”

The finalization was heralded by the city’s mayor and police commissioner as a necessary next step to reform. However, Sessions, who last week ordered the DOJ to review all consent decrees with local police departments, delivered an ominous statement that the decree in Baltimore will “reduce the lawful powers of the police department and result in a less safe city.” Sessions accused the agreement of being hastily constructed and criticized the level of oversight as well as the compensation of the monitor charged with ensuring the provisions of the decree are abided by.

The consent decree will take effect immediately and address how police are to interact with the public as well as outlines new training mandates, including in de-escalation tactics. Consent decrees have been found to be largely effective in instituting meaningful reform.

This summer an investigation by the Obama DOJ found that the policies and practices of the Baltimore Police Department systematically violated the civil rights of black residents. In a scathing 163 page report, the DOJ describes how the Baltimore Police Department consistently conducted searches and arrests with little to no probable cause, meticulously buried citizen complaints of racial discrimination, and failed to investigate reports of sexual assault—even at times committing these assaults themselves—as well as a host of other inexcusable offenses.

The DOJ found that “BPD’s Sex Offense Unit often questioned victims in a manner that put the blame for the sexual assault on the victim’s shoulders—for example, with questions suggesting the victims should feel personally responsible for the potential consequences of a criminal report on a suspect or for having engaged in behavior that invited the assault.” The DOJ found evidence that a detective in the Sex Offense Unit described 90 percent of sexual assault allegations as “bullshit” and a prosecutor referred to a victim as a “conniving little whore.”

The Obama DOJ made a point of investigating over two dozen police departments for unconstitutional practices, enforcing 14 consent decrees to initiate widespread change in cities such as Ferguson, Missouri. Civil rights advocates praised Obama’s efforts as improving relationships between community members and law enforcement officers.

But the DOJ under President Trump and Attorney General Sessions appears to be detouring from that route. Sessions’ DOJ has already withdrawn two Obama era civil rights objections. One was the attempt to protect transgender students’ access to the restroom that corresponded with their gender identity as a condition of the educational equity guarantee under Title X. Next, the DOJ withdrew the Obama era objection to Texas’ draconian voter ID law, claiming they no longer believed the law was passed with discriminatory intent.

As a state’s attorney general and as a United States Senator, Jeff Sessions was far from a champion of women’s and civil rights, a fact that made him one of Trump’s most controversial Cabinet nominees. Sessions has not been steadfast in condemning violence against women, voting against the re-authorization of the Violence Against Women Act because of its expansion to immigrant women, Native American women and college students. Sessions vigorously opposed the 2009 Hate Crimes Prevention Act as well as the Voting Rights Act, calling it “intrusive” while minimizing the voter suppression tactics used in the South.

After tapes were released of then-Presidential candidate Trump gloating that he grabs women by the genitals without consent, Sessions notoriously remarked that he didn’t believe that act of violence legally constituted as sexual assault, a comment that was very concerning to survivors and advocates.

 

Media Resources: Mother Jones 4/7/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 8/10/16, 8/18/16, 2/28/17, 2/9/17; The Daily Beast 4/7/17

 

 

Neil Gorsuch Confirmed to the Supreme Court

On Friday, the Senate confirmed Neil Gorsuch to serve as an Associate Justice on the United States Supreme Court by a vote of 54-45. He will be sworn in on Monday.

The day before the confirmation vote, 43 Senate Democrats and 2 Senate Independents made history filibustering Gorsuch, refusing to give him the longstanding 60-votes required to close the debate on a Supreme Court nominee. The goal of those Senators was to express to the Republicans, who hold a 52 seat majority in the Senate, that Gorsuch was a concerning candidate to serve on the Court and put pressure on the President to select a new mainstream nominee.

Instead, all 52 Senate Republicans led by Majority Leader Mitch McConnell voted to abandon 200 years of Senate tradition and employ the “nuclear option,” changing the rule requiring a 60-vote threshold for cloture, and forcing Gorsuch’s nomination through with only 55 votes.

The 60-vote threshold was put in place to ensure bi-partisan cooperation when it came to confirming a lifetime appointment to the highest Court in the land. Observers of the Senate and the Court now feel that without a 60-vote threshold, the Court will become even more polarized and politicized.

The seat Gorsuch will be filling has been vacant for over a year following the death of Justice Antonin Scalia and the refusal of Senate Republicans to even hold a hearing for Obama nominee Merrick Garland, a man widely considered to be the most moderate possible candidate for the job.

During his 20 hours of questioning by the Senate Judiciary Committee Gorsuch refused to provide substantive answers to even the most basic questions. In the morning of his second day of testimony, the Supreme Court, located just across the street, unanimously overturned one of his lower court rulings against the family of a child with autism who sought private school tuition reimbursement after their public school district failed to provide any substantive education to the child.

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), public schools are required to provide “free appropriate education” with meaningful benefits to children with disabilities. Gorsuch had ruled that the child had received an appropriate education because the school had provided barely more than “de minimis,” meaning “so minor as to merit disregard.” The Court unanimously overturned his decision, ruling that IDEA demanded that a child be making progress from year to year, not just simply be sitting around waiting until they were old enough to drop out.

This case was merely one of many in which Gorsuch read the word of the law so narrowly as to completely disregard the context or the impact that the law had on those in question. In 2009 he ruled against a victim of workplace sexual harassment because she had suffered through two months of abuse before filing a complaint. In 2013, he ruled that a University was justified in firing a professor recovering from Leukemia who asked to work from home at her doctor’s insistence during a widespread flu epidemic on campus, claiming the professor was requesting an unreasonable accommodation. In the infamous Hobby Lobby case, Gorsuch ruled that a corporation’s religious freedom trumped the right of women to access birth control. The list of cases goes on.

Thousands of grassroots activists and hundreds of civil rights, feminist, and other social justice organizations such as the Feminist Majority Foundation, NAACP, NARAL Pro-Choice America, National Organization for Women, and Planned Parenthood Federation publicly opposed Gorsuch due to his consistent rulings putting corporations above women, workers and everyday people.

 

Media Resources: New York Times 4/7/17; Think Progress 3/22/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 3/31/17; People for the American Way 3/2017.

Trump Repeals Fair Pay Order

Just before April 4th, also known as Equal Pay Day, President Donald Trump revoked an incredibly important executive order – the 2014 Fair Pay and Safe Workplaces order.

Implemented by President Barack Obama, the 2014 Fair Pay and Safe Workplaces order ensuring that companies with federal contracts are held accountable to fourteen labor laws. This same order goes to lengths to protect women in the work place by addressing two major workplace concerns: pay transparency and proceedings of sexual assault and discrimination claims.

The wage transparency clause requires companies with federal contracts to declare to their employee’s information such as specific deductions, rate of pay, and total hours worked. With this information, female employees can ensure they are paid the same as their male coworkers.

According to the Association of American University Women, women currently make an average of 80 cents to a man’s dollar, but the racial disparity in the gender wage gap is vast. Based on data from 2015, compared to white men, Asian women earned 90 percent, white (non-Hispanic) women earned 76 percent, black women earned 62 percent, Hawaiian/Pacific Islander women earned 60 percent, American Indian women earned 58 percent and Hispanic/Latina women earned 54 percent.

Another rule in the Fair Pay and Safe Workplaces order bans companies from implementing arbitration clauses in cases of sexual harassment or discrimination. These arbitration clauses have been used to silence victims of harassment by keeping claims of harassment and discrimination out of the courts. Arbitration clauses received public attention after Gretchen Carlson, a Fox Newscaster, ignored the arbitration clause in her contract and sued the former Chief of Fox News, Roger Ailes.

Women’s rights activists are calling attention to President Trump’s actions. Noreen Farrell from Equal Rights Advocates referred to the revocation as “an outrage” and many consider this to be a serious blow in the fight towards the goal of equal pay. Trump used the Congressional Review Act (CRA) to repeal the Fair Pay and Safe Workplaces Act which means the law can never be reinstated by the executive branch.

Media Resources: Independent 4/5/2017; Association of American University Women; Feminist Majority Foundation 4/4/17 ; NBC News 4/3/17 ; New York Magazine 3/27/17

Today is Equal Pay Day

Today is Equal Pay Day, marking the point into the year 2017 that women in America need to work to in order to accumulate the same amount of income that men earned in 2016. The commemorative day is always held on a Tuesday to represent how far into the next week women must work to earn the amount made by men in the previous week.

According to the Association of American University Women, women currently make an average of 80 cents to a man’s dollar, but the racial disparity in the gender wage gap is vast. Based on data from 2015, compared to white men, Asian women earned 90 percent, white (non-Hispanic) women earned 76 percent, black women earned 62 percent, Hawaiian/Pacific Islander women earned 60 percent, American Indian women earned 58 percent and Hispanic/Latina women earned 54 percent.

As women get older, the gender wage gap tends to widen. Typically women earn about 90 percent of what men earn until they reach age 35, at which point their wage percentages lower to an average of 74-82 percent of what a man makes. The gender wage gap does not narrow based on a woman’s education level when compared with men of the same educational background.

The fight for gender pay equity on the federal level has been a back and forth tug for over 60 years now. The first Equal Pay Law was signed by President Kennedy in 1963, making it illegal to pay women less money for doing the same job. However, a Supreme Court ruling later limited the amount of time that a woman could file a wage discrimination suit against her employer to within 180 days of the first discriminatory pay check. In 2009, President Obama signed the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, allowing women to file suit for wage discrimination no matter how much time had passed since the discrimination first began.

In 2014, Senate Republicans unanimously blocked a bill that would have made it illegal for employers to punish employees who discussed their wages. Democrats had hoped the bill would empower women and others to have constructive conversations about their position responsibilities and salaries. Likewise, a rule passed by the Obama administration in an effort to combat wage discrimination by requiring large employers to report data on their employee’s pay checks broken down by race, gender and ethnicity is currently being reviewed by the Trump White House’s Office of Management and Budget at the request of a coalition of business associations.

On Equal Pay Day, Representative Rosa DeLauro intends to introduce the Paycheck Fairness Act for the 11th time. The bill aims to strengthen discriminated worker’s position in court, end retaliation against workers who speak out, and improve federal enforcement capabilities concerning anti-discrimination laws.

There have been some successes on the state level. This summer, Massachusetts Governor Charlie Baker (R) signed into law what is arguably the nation’s strongest equal pay measure, requiring employers to pay men and women the same for comparable work. The law is also the first in the country to ban employers from asking applicants about their salary histories. In addition, the law bans the practice of pay secrecy, wherein employers prevent their employees from discussing each other’s salaries.

This past November, voters in Arizona, Colorado, Maine and Washington successfully passed ballot measures to raise their minimum wages in light of Congress’ refusal to touch the federal minimum of $7.25 an hour. Two-thirds of minimum wage workers are women and the raises in those four states are expected to benefit around 2.1 million people. According to POLITICO, state ballot initiatives to raise the minimum wage have appeared 20 times in the last 20 years, and have only failed twice, both times in 1996 only three months after a federal minimum wage increase.

But the fight for gender pay equity is a global one. Women in France and Iceland held large-scale walk outs in 2016, leaving work at 4:34 pm and 2:38 pm respectively to protest the gender pay gap. Women in Europe are paid on average 16 percent less than what their male colleagues make. It is estimated that it will take 169 years to close the global gender pay gap.

Media Resources: NBC News 4/4/17; American Association of University Women, Spring 2017; USA Today 4/3/17; Feminist Majority Foundation 8/1/16, 11/10/16, 11/7/16, 10/25/16

Gay Men in Chechnya Targeted by Police

Reports of a “round up” of 100 gay men in Chechnya sparked international outrage this weekend after a Russian newspaper reported that 3 men had been killed in the process.

The Novaya Gazeta, a Russian newspaper, reported Saturday that they had evidence to prove that Chechen authorities targeted and apprehended 100 gay men. The same report states that during the “round up” at least 3 men were killed.  Although the allegations only come from one source, human rights activists in the region report that they have heard similar rumors over the past week.

Because of the republic’s hostility towards LGBTQ people, confirmation of such rumors by family members is almost impossible to obtain. The Novaya Gazeta states that while 3 men were killed, more could be in danger of being returned to their families under the assumption their family members will carry out “honor killings.”

Chechnya, a former republic of Russia, is known as a highly conservative Muslim state under the leadership of current President Ramzan Kadyrov. Kadyrov has been criticized by human rights activists for encouraging polygamy, passing laws that force women to wear hijabs in public, and subjecting members of the LGBTQ community to discrimination and even violence. The spokesperson for Kadyrov stated that the accusations made by the Novaya Gazeta were “absolute lies” and went on to claim that “you cannot detain and persecute people who simply do not exist in the republic.”

Russia, much like Chechnya, is known for hostile attitudes towards the LGBTQ community, highlighted by the 2013 “gay propaganda” law that sparked international scrutiny. According to this law, propaganda of any “non-traditional” relations cannot be spread among minors with the goal of promoting and protecting conservative values. Although major Russian cities are known to have large LGBTQ underground communities, LGBTQ rights activists still face violence and unlawful detention.

Media resources: The Guardian 4/2/17, 6/11/13 ; NCB 4/3/17 ; The Independent 4/3/17 ; Huffington Post 5/30/15

>